‘Shameless! A mon – ony mon – that’s a’ tha thinks on. Bide till tha’s wanted. What’s this?’
Voices – voices – ever so many fierce faces peering down all round.
‘Peter’s Pot? An’ what were ’ee a-wanting on t’moor this time night? No good. Nobody but a fool or a thief’ud coom oop ’ere i’ t’ fog.’
One of the men, a farm labourer with wry shoulders and a thin, malicious face suddenly burst into tuneless song:
‘I been a-courtin’ Mary Jane
On Ilka’ Moor baht ’at.’
‘Howd toong!’ yelled Grimethorpe, in a fury. ‘Doost want Ah should break ivery bwoan i’ thi body!’ He turned on Bunter. ‘Tak thesen off, Ah tell tha. Tha’art here for no good.’
‘But, William –’ began his wife. He snapped round at her like a dog, and she shrank back.
‘Naay now, naay now,’ said a man, whom Wimsey dimly recognised as the fellow who had befriended him on his previous visit, ’tha mun’ taak them in for t’night, racken, or there’ll be trouble wi’ t’ folk down yonder at t’ Lodge, lat aloan what police ’ull saay. Ef t’ fellow ’m coom to do harm, ’ee’s doon it already – to ’unself. Woan’t do no more tonight – look at un. Bring ’un to fire, mon,’ he added to Bunter, and then, turning to the farmer again, ‘ ’Tes tha’ll be in Queer Street ef ’e wor to goo an’ die on us wi’ noomony or rhoomaticks.’
This reasoning seemed partly to convince Grimethorpe. He made way, grumbling, and the two chilled and exhausted men were brought near the fire. Somebody brought two large, steaming tumblers of spirits. Wimsey’s brain seemed to clear, then swim again drowsily, drunkenly.
Presently he became aware that he was being carried upstairs and put to bed. A big, old-fashioned room, with a fire on the hearth and a huge, grim four-poster. Bunter was helping him out of soaked clothes; rubbing him. Another man appeared from time to time to help him. From below came the bellowing sound of Grimethorpe’s voice, blasphemously uplifted. Then the harsh, brassy singing of the wry-shouldered man:
‘Then woorms will coom an’ ate thee oop
On Ilkla’ Moor baht ’at . . .
Then doocks will coom an’ ate oop woorms
On Ilkla’ Moor . . .’
Lord Peter rolled into bed.
‘Bunter – where – you all right? Never said thank you – dunno what. I’m doing – anywhere to sleep – what?’
He drifted away into oblivion. The old song came up mockingly, and wound its horrible fancies into his dreams:
Then we shall coom an’ ate oop doocks
On Ilkla’ Moor baht ’at . . .
An’ that is how – an’ that is how – is how . . .
When Wimsey next opened his eyes a pale November sun was struggling in at the window. It seemed that the fog had fulfilled its mission and departed. For some time he lay, vaguely unaware of how he came to be where he was; then the outlines of recollection straightened themselves, the drifting outposts of dreams were called back, the burden of his preoccupation settled down as usual. He became aware of an extreme bodily lassitude, and of the dragging pain of wrenched shoulder muscles. Examining himself perfunctorily, he found a bruised and tender zone beneath the armpits and round his chest and back, where the rescuing rope had hauled at him. It was painful to move, so he lay back and closed his eyes once more.
Presently the door opened to admit Bunter, neatly clothed and bearing a tray from which rose a most excellent odour of ham and eggs.
‘Hullo, Bunter?’
‘Good morning, my lord! I trust your lordship has rested.’
‘Feel as fit as a fiddle, thanks – come to think of it, why fiddle? – except for a general feeling of havin’ been violently massaged by some fellow with cast-iron fingers and knobbly joints. How about you?’
‘The arms are a trifle fatigued, thank you, my lord; otherwise, I am happy to say, I feel no trace of the misadventure. Allow me, my lord.’
He set the tray tenderly upon Lord Peter’s ready knees.
‘They must be jolly well dragged out of their sockets,’ said his lordship, ‘holdin’ me up all that ghastly long time. I’m so beastly deep in debt to you already, Bunter, it’s not a bit of use tryin’ to repay it. You know I won’t forget, anyhow, don’t you? All right, I won’t be embarrassin’ or anything – thanks awfully, anyhow. That’s that. What? Did they give you anywhere decent to sleep? I didn’t seem to be able to sit up an’ take notice last night.’
‘I slept excellently, I thank your lordship.’ Mr Bunter indicated a kind of truckle-bed in a corner of the room. ‘They would have given me another room, my lord, but in the circumstances, I preferred to remain with your lordship, trusting you would excuse the liberty. I told them that I feared the effects of prolonged immersion upon your lordship’s health. I was uneasy, besides, about the intention of Grimethorpe. I feared he might not feel altogether hospitably disposed, and that he might be led into some hasty action if we were not together.’
‘I shouldn’t wonder. Most murderous-lookin’ fellow I ever set eyes on. I’ll have to talk to him this morning – or to Mrs Grimethorpe. I’d take my oath she could tell us something, what?’
‘I should say there was very little doubt of it, my word,’
‘Trouble is,’ pursued Wimsey, with his mouth full of egg, ‘I don’t know how to get at her. That jolly husband of hers seems to cherish the most unpleasant suspicions of anything that comes this way in trousers. If he found out we’d been talking to her, what you may call privately, he might, as you say, be hurried by his feelin’s into doin’ something regrettable.’
‘Just so, my lord.’
‘Still, the fellow must go an’ look after his bally old farm some time, and then, p’raps, we’ll be able to tackle her. Queer sort of woman – damn fine one, what? Wonder what she made of Cathcart?’ he added musingly.
Mr Bunter volunteered no opinion on this delicate point.
‘Well, Bunter, I think I’ll get up. I don’t suppose we’re altogether welcome here. I didn’t fancy the look in our host’s eye last night.’
‘No, my lord. He made a deal of opposition about having your lordship conveyed to this room.’
‘Why, whose room is it?’
‘His own and Mrs Grimethorpe’s, my lord. It appeared most suitable, there being a fireplace, and the bed already made up. Mrs Grimethorpe showed great kindness, my lord, and the man Jake pointed out to Grimethorpe that it would doubtless be to his pecuniary advantage to treat your lordship with consideration.’
‘H’m. Nice, graspin’ character, ain’t he? Well, it’s up and away for me. O Lord! I am stiff. I say, Bunter, have I any clothes to put on?’
‘I have dried and brushed your lordship’s suit to the best of my ability, my lord. It is not as I should wish to see it, but I think your lordship will be able to wear it to Riddlesdale.’
‘Well, I don’t suppose the streets will be precisely crowded,’ retorted his lordship. ‘I do so want a hot bath. How about shavin’ water?’
‘I can procure that from the kitchen, my lord.’
Bunter padded away, and Lord Peter, having pulled on a shirt and trousers with many grunts and groans, roamed over to the window. As usual with hardy country dwellers, it was tightly shut, and a thick wedge of paper had been rammed in to keep the sash from rattling. He removed this and flung up the sash. The wind rollicked in, laden with peaty moor scents. He drank it in gladly. It was good to see the jolly old sun after all – he would have hated to die a sticky death in Peter’s Pot. For a few minutes he stood there, returning thanks vaguely in his mind for the benefits of existence. Then he withdrew to finish dressing. The wad of paper was still in his hand, and he was about to fling it into the fire, when a word caught his eye. He unrolled the paper. As he read it his eyebrows went up and his mouth pursed itself into an indescribable expression of whimsical enlightenment. Bunter, returning with the hot water, found his master transfixed, the paper in one hand, and his socks in the other,
and whistling a complicated passage of Bach under his breath.
‘Bunter,’ said his lordship, ‘I am, without exception, the biggest ass in Christendom. When a thing is close under my nose I can’t see it. I get a telescope, and look for the explanation in Stapley. I deserve to be crucified upside-down, as a cure for anaemia of the brain. Jerry! Jerry! But, naturally, of course, you rotten ass, isn’t it obvious? Silly old blighter. Why couldn’t he tell Murbles or me?’
Mr Bunter advanced, the picture of respectful inquiry.
‘Look at it – look at it!’ said Wimsey, with a hysterical squeak of laughter. ‘Oh Lord! O Lord! Stuck into the window frame for anybody to find. Just like Jerry. Signs his name to the business in letters a foot long, leaves it conspicuously about, and then goes away and is chivalrously silent.’
Mr Bunter put the jug down upon the washstand in case of accident, and took the paper.
It was the missing letter from Tommy Freeborn.
No doubt about it. There it was – the evidence which established the truth of Denver’s evidence. More – which established his alibi for the night of the 13th.
Not Cathcart – Denver.
Denver suggesting that the shooting party should return in October to Riddlesdale, where they had opened the grouse season in August. Denver sneaking hurriedly out at 11.30 to walk two miles across the fields on a night when Farmer Grimethorpe had gone to buy machinery. Denver carelessly plugging a rattling sash on a stormy night with an important letter bearing his title on it for all to see. Denver padding back at three in the morning like a homing tom-cat, to fall over his guest’s dead body by the conservatory. Denver, with his kind, stupid, English-gentleman ideas about honour, going obstinately off to prison, rather than tell his solicitor where he had been. Denver misleading them all into the wildest and most ingenious solutions of a mystery which now stood out clear as seven sunbeams. Denver, whose voice the woman had thought she recognised on the memorable day when she flung herself into the arms of his brother. Denver calmly setting in motion the enormous, creaking machinery of a trial by his noble peers in order to safeguard a woman’s reputation.
This very day, probably, a Select Committee of lords was sitting ‘to inspect the Journals of this House upon former trials of peers in criminal cases, in order to bring the Duke of Denver to a speedy trial, and to report to the House what they should think proper thereupon.’ There they were: moving that an address be presented to His Majesty by the lords with white staves, to acquaint His Majesty of the date proposed for the trial; arranging for fitting up the Royal Gallery at Westminster; humbly requesting the attendance of a sufficient police force to keep clear the approaches leading to the House; petitioning His Majesty graciously to appoint a Lord High Steward; ordering, in sheep-like accordance with precedent, that all lords be summoned to attend in their robes; that every lord, in giving judgement, disclose his opinion upon his honour, laying his right hand upon his heart; that the Sergeant-at-Arms be within the House to make proclamations in the King’s name for keeping silence – and so on, and on, unendingly. And there, jammed in the window-sash, was the dirty little bit of paper which, discovered earlier, would have made the whole monstrous ceremonial unnecessary.
Wimsey’s adventure in the bog had unsettled his nerves. He sat down on the bed and laughed, with the tears streaming down his face.
Mr Bunter was speechless. Speechlessly he produced a razor – and to the end of his days Wimsey never knew how or from whom he had so adequately procured it – and began to strop it thoughtfully upon the palm of his hand.
Presently Wimsey pulled himself together and staggered for a little cooling draught of moor air. As he did so, a loud hullabaloo smote his ear, and he perceived, in the courtyard below, Farmer Grimethorpe striding among his dogs; when they howled he struck at them with a whip, and they howled again. Suddenly he glanced up at the window, with an expression of such livid hatred that Wimsey stepped hurriedly back as though struck.
While Bunter shaved him he was silent.
The interview before Lord Peter was a delicate one; the situation, however one looked at it, unpleasant. He was under a considerable debt of gratitude to his hostess; on the other hand, Denver’s position was such that minor considerations really had to go to the wall. His lordship had, nevertheless, never felt quite such a cad as he did while descending the staircase at Grider’s Hole.
In the big farm kitchen he found a stout country-woman, stirring a pot of stew. He asked for Mr Grimethorpe, and was told that he had gone out.
‘Can I speak to Mrs Grimethorpe, please?’
The woman looked doubtfully at him, wiped her hands on her apron, and, going into the scullery, shouted, ‘Mrs Grimethorpe!’ A voice replied from somewhere outside.
‘Gentleman wants see tha.’
‘Where is Mrs Grimethorpe?’ broke in Peter hurriedly.
‘I’ t’dairy, recken.’
‘I’ll go to her there,’ said Wimsey, stepping briskly out. He passed through a stone-paved scullery, and across a yard, in time to see Mrs Grimethorpe emerging from a dark doorway opposite.
Framed there, the cold sunlight just lighting upon her still, dead-white face and heavy, dark hair, she was more wonderful than ever. There was no trace of Yorkshire descent in the long, dark eyes and curled mouth. The curve of nose and cheekbones vouched for an origin immensely remote; coming out of the darkness, she might have just risen from her far tomb in the Pyramids, dropping the dry and perfumed grave-bands from her fingers.
Lord Peter pulled himself together.
‘Foreign,’ he said to himself matter-of-factly. ‘Touch of Jew perhaps, or Spanish, is it? Remarkable type. Don’t blame Jerry. Couldn’t live with Helen myself. Now for it.’
He advanced quickly.
‘Good morning,’ she said, ‘are you better?’
‘Perfectly all right, thank you – thanks to your kindness, which I do not know how to repay.’
‘You will repay any kindness best by going at once,’ she answered in her remote voice. ‘My husband does not care for strangers, and ’twas unfortunate the way you met before.’
‘I will go directly. But I must first beg for the favour of a word with you.’ He peered past her into the dimness of the dairy. ‘In there, perhaps?’
‘What do you want with me?’
She stepped back, however, and allowed him to follow her in.
‘Mrs Grimethorpe, I am placed in a most painful position. You know that my brother, the Duke of Denver, is in prison, awaiting his trial for a murder which took place on the night of October 13th?’
Her face did not change. ‘I have heard so.’
‘He has, in the most decided manner, refused to state where he was between eleven and three on that night. His refusal has brought him into great danger of his life.’
She looked at him steadily.
‘He feels bound in honour not to disclose his whereabouts, though I know that, if he chose to speak, he could bring a witness to clear him.’
‘He seems to be a very honourable man.’ The cold voice wavered a trifle, then steadied again.
‘Yes. Undoubtedly, from his point of view, he is doing the right thing. You will understand, however, that, as his brother, I am naturally anxious to have the matter put in its proper light.’
‘I don’t understand why you are telling me all this. I suppose, if the thing is disgraceful, he doesn’t want it known.’
‘Obviously. But to us – to his wife and young son, and to his sister and myself – his life and safety are matters of the first importance.’
‘Of more importance than his honour?’
‘The secret is a disgraceful one in a sense, and will give pain to his family. But it would be an infinitely greater disgrace that he should be executed for murder. The stigma in that case would involve all those who bear his name. The shame of the truth will, I fear, in this very unjust society of ours, rest more upon the witness to his alibi than upon himself.’
‘C
an you in that case expect the witness to come forward?’
‘To prevent the condemnation of an innocent man? Yes, I think I may venture to expect even that.’
‘I repeat – why are you telling me all this?’
‘Because, Mrs Grimethorpe, you know, even better than I, how innocent my brother is of this murder. Believe me, I am deeply distressed at having to say these things to you.’
‘I know nothing about your brother.’
‘Forgive me, that is not true.’
‘I know nothing. And surely, if the Duke will not speak, you should respect his reasons.’
‘I am not bound in any way.’
‘I am afraid I cannot help you. You are wasting time. If you cannot produce your missing witness, why do you not set about finding the real murderer? If you do so you surely need not trouble about this alibi. Your brother’s movements are his own business.’
‘I could wish,’ said Wimsey, ‘you had not taken up this attitude. Believe me, I would have done all I could to spare you. I have been working hard to find, as you say, the real murderer, but with no success. The trial will probably take place at the end of the month.’
Her lips twitched a little at that, but she said nothing.
‘I had hoped that with your help we might agree on some explanation – less than the truth, perhaps, but sufficient to clear my brother. As it is, I fear I shall have to produce the proof I hold, and let matters take their course.’
That, at last, struck under her guard. A dull flush crept up her checks; one hand tightened upon the handle of the churn, where she had rested it.
‘What do you mean by proof?’
‘I can prove that on the night of the 13th my brother slept in the room I occupied last night,’ said Wimsey, with calculated brutality.