The president was not convinced by Bundy. "The situation is moving there, Mac."
Bundy persisted. "The justification for this message is that we expect it to be turned down."
Really? thought George. He was pretty sure President Kennedy and his brother did not see it that way.
"We expect to be acting against Cuba tomorrow or the next day," Bundy went on. "What's our military plan?"
This was not how George had thought the meeting would go. They should be talking about peace, not war.
Defense Secretary Bob McNamara, the whiz kid from Ford, answered the question. "A large air strike leading to invasion." Then he turned the argument back to Turkey. "To minimize the Soviet response against NATO following a U.S. attack on Cuba, we get those Jupiters out of Turkey before the Cuban attack--and let the Soviets know. On that basis, I don't believe the Soviets would strike Turkey."
That was ironic, George thought: to protect Turkey, it was necessary to take away its nuclear weapons.
Secretary of State Dean Rusk, who George thought was one of the smarter men in the room, warned: "They might take some other action--in Berlin."
George marveled that the American president could not attack a Caribbean island without calculating the repercussions five thousand miles away in Eastern Europe. It showed how the entire planet was a chess board for the two superpowers.
McNamara said: "I'm not prepared at this moment to recommend air attacks on Cuba. I'm just saying we must now begin to look at it more realistically."
General Maxwell Taylor spoke. He had been in touch with the Joint Chiefs of Staff. "The recommendation they give is that the big strike, Operations Plan 312, be executed no later than Monday morning, unless there is irrefutable evidence in the meantime that offensive weapons are being dismantled."
Sitting behind Taylor, Mawhinney and his friends looked pleased. Just like the military, George thought: they could hardly wait to go into battle, even though it might mean the end of the world. He prayed that the politicians in the room would not be guided by the soldiers.
Taylor continued: "And that the execution of this strike plan be followed by the execution of 316, the invasion plan, seven days later."
Bobby Kennedy said sarcastically: "Well, I'm surprised."
There was loud laughter around the table. Everyone thought the military's recommendations were absurdly predictable, it seemed. George felt relieved.
But the mood became grim again when McNamara, reading a note passed to him by an aide, suddenly said: "The U-2 was shot down."
George gasped. He knew that a CIA spy plane had gone silent during a mission over Cuba, but everyone was hoping it had suffered a radio problem and was on its way home.
President Kennedy evidently had not been briefed about the missing plane. "A U-2 was shot down?" he said, and there was fear in his voice.
George knew why the president was appalled. Until this moment, the superpowers had been nose to nose, but all they had done was threaten one another. Now the first shot had been fired. From this point on, it would be much more difficult to avoid war.
"Wright just said it was found shot down," McNamara said. Colonel John Wright was with the Defense Intelligence Agency.
Bobby said: "Was the pilot killed?"
As so often, he had asked the key question.
General Taylor said: "The pilot's body is in the plane."
President Kennedy said: "Did anyone see the pilot?"
"Yes, sir," Taylor replied. "The wreckage is on the ground and the pilot's dead."
The room went quiet. This changed everything. An American was dead, shot down in Cuba by Soviet guns.
Taylor said: "That raises the question of retaliation."
It certainly did. The American people would demand revenge. George felt the same. Suddenly he yearned for the president to launch the massive air attack that the Pentagon had demanded. In his mind he saw hundreds of bombers in close formation sweeping across the Florida Straits and dropping their deadly payload on Cuba like a hailstorm. He wanted every missile launcher blown up, all the Soviet troops slaughtered, Castro killed. If the entire Cuban nation suffered, so be it: that would teach them not to kill Americans.
The meeting had been going on for two hours, and the room was foggy with tobacco smoke. The president announced a break. It was a good idea, George thought. George himself certainly needed to calm down. If the others were feeling as bloodthirsty as he was, they were in no state to make rational decisions.
The more important reason for the break, George knew, was that President Kennedy had to take his medicine. Most people knew he had a bad back, but few understood that he fought a constant battle against a whole range of ailments, including Addison's disease and colitis. Twice a day the doctors shot him up with a cocktail of steroids and antibiotics to keep him functioning.
Bobby undertook to redraft the letter to Khrushchev, with the help of the president's cheerful young speechwriter Ted Sorensen. The two of them went with their aides to the president's study, a cramped room next to the Oval Office. George took a pen and yellow pad and wrote down everything Bobby told him to. With only two people discussing it, the draft was done quickly.
The key paragraphs were:
1. You would agree to remove these weapons systems from Cuba under appropriate United Nations observation and supervision; and undertake, with suitable safeguards, to halt the further introduction of such weapons systems into Cuba.
2. We, on our part, would agree--upon the establishment of adequate arrangements through the United Nations to ensure the carrying out and continuation of these commitments--(a) to remove promptly the quarantine arrangements now in effect and (b) to give assurances against an invasion of Cuba and I am confident that other nations of the Western Hemisphere would be prepared to do likewise.
The USA was accepting Khrushchev's first offer. But what about his second? Bobby and Sorensen agreed to say:
The effect of such a settlement on easing world tensions would enable us to work toward a more general arrangement regarding "other armaments" as proposed in your second letter.
It was not much, just a hint of a promise to discuss something, but it was probably the most that ExComm would allow.
George privately wondered how this could possibly be enough.
He gave his handwritten draft to one of the president's secretaries and asked her to get it typed. A few minutes later, Bobby was summoned to the Oval Office, where a smaller group was gathering: the president, Dean Rusk, Mac Bundy, and two or three others, with their closest aides. Vice President Lyndon Johnson was excluded: he was a smart political operator, in George's opinion, but his rough Texas manners grated on the refined Boston Kennedy brothers.
The president wanted Bobby to carry the letter personally to the Soviet ambassador in Washington, Anatoly Dobrynin. Bobby and Dobrynin had had several informal meetings in the last few days. They did not much like one another, but they were able to speak frankly, and had formed a useful back channel that bypassed the Washington bureaucracy. In a face-to-face meeting, perhaps Bobby could expand on the hint of a promise to discuss the missiles in Turkey--without getting prior approval from ExComm.
Dean Rusk suggested that Bobby could go a little further with Dobrynin. In today's meetings it had become clear that no one really wanted the Jupiter missiles to remain in Turkey. From a strictly military point of view they were useless. The problem was cosmetic: the Turkish government and the other NATO allies would be angered if the USA traded those missiles in a Cuba settlement. Rusk suggested a solution that George thought was very smart. "Offer to pull the Jupiters out later--say, in five or six months' time," said Rusk. "Then we can do it quietly, with the agreement of our allies, and step up the Mediterranean activity of our nuclear-armed submarines to compensate. But the Soviets have to promise to keep that deal deadly secret."
It was a startling suggestion, but brilliant, George thought.
Everyone agreed with remarkable speed. ExComm d
iscussions had rambled all over the globe for most of the day, but this smaller group here in the Oval Office had suddenly become decisive. Bobby said to George: "Call Dobrynin." He looked at his watch, and George did the same: it was seven fifteen P.M. "Ask him to meet me at the Justice Department in half an hour," Bobby said.
The president added: "And release the letter to the press fifteen minutes later."
George stepped into the secretaries' office next to the Oval Office and picked up a phone. "Get me the Soviet embassy," he said to the switchboard operator.
The ambassador agreed instantly to the meeting.
George took the typed letter to Maria and told her the president wanted it released to the press at eight P.M.
She looked anxiously at her watch, then said: "Okay, girls, we'd better go to work."
Bobby and George left the White House and a car drove them the few blocks to the Justice Department. In the gloomy weekend lighting, the statues in the Great Hall seemed to watch the two men suspiciously. George explained to the security staff that an important visitor would shortly arrive to see Bobby.
They went up in the elevator. George thought Bobby looked exhausted, and undoubtedly he was. The corridors of the huge building echoed emptily. Bobby's cavernous office was dimly lit, but he did not bother to switch on more lamps. He slumped behind his wide desk and rubbed his eyes.
George looked out of the window at the streetlights. The center of Washington was a pretty park full of monuments and palaces, but the rest of it was a densely populated metropolis with five million residents, more than half of them black. Would the city be here this time tomorrow? George had seen pictures of Hiroshima: miles of buildings flattened to rubble, and burned and maimed survivors on the outskirts, staring with uncomprehending eyes at the unrecognizable world around them. Would Washington look like that in the morning?
Ambassador Dobrynin was shown in at exactly a quarter to eight. He was a bald man in his early forties, and he clearly relished his informal meetings with the president's brother.
"I want to lay out the current alarming situation the way the president sees it," Bobby said. "One of our planes has been shot down over Cuba and the pilot is dead."
"Your planes have no right to fly over Cuba," Dobrynin said quickly.
Bobby's discussions with Dobrynin could be combative, but today the attorney general was in a different mood. "I want you to understand the political realities," he said. "There is now strong pressure on the president to respond with fire. We can't stop these overflights: it's the only way we can check the state of construction of your missile bases. But if the Cubans shoot at our planes, we're going to shoot back."
Bobby told Dobrynin what was in the letter from President Kennedy to Secretary Khrushchev.
"And what about Turkey?" Dobrynin said sharply.
Bobby replied carefully. "If that is the only obstacle to achieving the regulation I mentioned earlier, the president doesn't see any insurmountable difficulties. The greatest difficulty for the president is the public discussion of the issue. If such a decision were announced now it would tear NATO apart. We need four to five months to remove the missiles from Turkey. But this is extremely confidential: only a handful of people know that I am saying this to you."
George watched Dobrynin's face carefully. Was it his imagination, or was the diplomat concealing a rush of excitement?
Bobby said: "George, give the ambassador the phone numbers we use to get to the president directly."
George grabbed a pad, wrote down three numbers, tore off the sheet, and handed it to Dobrynin.
Bobby stood up, and the ambassador did the same. "I need an answer tomorrow," Bobby said. "That's not an ultimatum, it's the reality. Our generals are itching for a fight. And don't send us one of those long Khrushchev letters that take all day to translate. We need a clear, businesslike answer from you, Mr. Ambassador. And we need it fast."
"Very well," said the Russian, and he went out.
*
On Sunday morning, the KGB station chief in Havana reported to the Kremlin that the Cubans now thought an American attack was inevitable.
Dimka was at a government dacha at Novo-Ogaryevo, a picturesque village on the outskirts of Moscow. The dacha was a small place with white columns that made it look a bit like the White House in Washington. Dimka was preparing for the Presidium meeting to be held here in a few minutes, at twelve noon. He went around the long oak table with eighteen briefing folders, putting one in each place. They contained President Kennedy's latest message to Khrushchev, translated into Russian.
Dimka felt hopeful. The American president had agreed to everything Khrushchev had originally demanded. If this letter had arrived, miraculously, minutes after Khrushchev's first message had been sent, the crisis would have been over instantly. But the delay had permitted Khrushchev to add to his demands. And, unfortunately, Kennedy's letter did not directly mention Turkey. Dimka did not know whether that would be a sticking point for his boss.
The Presidium members were assembling when Natalya Smotrov came into the room. Dimka noticed first that her curly hair was getting longer and sexier, and second that she looked scared. He had been trying to get a few minutes with her to tell her about his engagement. He felt he could not give the news to anyone in the Kremlin until he had told Natalya. But once again this was not a good moment. He needed her alone.
She came straight to him and said: "Those imbeciles have shot down an American plane."
"Oh, no!"
She nodded. "A U-2 spy plane. The pilot is dead."
"Shit! Who did it, us or the Cubans?"
"No one will say, which means it was probably us."
"But no such order was given!"
"Exactly."
This was what they had both feared: that someone would start the shooting without authorization.
The members were taking their seats, aides behind them as usual. "I'll go and tell him," Dimka said but, as he spoke, Khrushchev came in. Dimka hurried to his side and murmured the news in the leader's ear as he sat down. Khrushchev did not reply, but looked grim.
He opened the meeting with what was clearly a prepared speech. "There was a time when we advanced, as in October 1917; but in March 1918 we had to retreat, having signed the Brest-Litovsk agreement with the Germans," he began. "Now we find ourselves face-to-face with the danger of war and nuclear catastrophe, with the possible result of destroying the human race. In order to save the world, we must retreat."
That sounded like the beginning of an argument for compromise, Dimka thought.
But Khrushchev quickly turned to military considerations. What should the Soviet Union do if the Americans were to attack Cuba today, as the Cubans themselves fully expected? General Pliyev must be instructed to defend Soviet forces in Cuba. But he should ask permission before using nuclear weapons.
While the Presidium was discussing that possibility, Dimka was called out of the room by Vera Pletner, his secretary. There was a phone call for him.
Natalya followed him out.
The Foreign Ministry had news that must be passed to Khrushchev immediately--yes, in the middle of the meeting. A cable had just been received from the Soviet ambassador in Washington. Bobby Kennedy had told him the missiles in Turkey would be removed in four or five months--but this must be kept deadly secret.
"This is good news!" Dimka said delightedly. "I'll tell him right away."
"One more thing," said the Foreign Ministry official. "Bobby kept stressing the need for speed. Apparently the American president is under severe pressure from the Pentagon to attack Cuba."
"Just as we thought."
"Bobby kept saying there is very little time. They must have their answer today."
"I'll tell him."
He hung up. Natalya was standing beside him, looking expectant. She had a nose for news. He told her: "Bobby Kennedy offered to remove the missiles from Turkey."
She smiled broadly. "It's over!" she said. "We've won!" Then
she kissed him on the lips.
Dimka went back into the room in high excitement. Malinovsky, the defense minister, was speaking. Dimka went up to Khrushchev and said in a low voice: "A cable from Dobrynin--he's received a new offer from Bobby Kennedy."
"Tell everyone," Khrushchev said, interrupting the speaker.
Dimka repeated what he had been told.
Presidium members rarely smiled, but Dimka now saw broad grins around the table. Kennedy had given them everything they had asked for! It was a triumph for the Soviet Union and for Khrushchev personally.
"We must accept as quickly as possible," Khrushchev said. "Bring in a stenographer. I will dictate our letter of acceptance immediately, and it must be broadcast on Radio Moscow."
Malinovsky said: "When should I instruct Pliyev to start dismantling the missile launchers?"
Khrushchev looked at him as if he were stupid. "Now," he said.
*
After the Presidium, Dimka at last got Natalya alone. She was sitting in an anteroom, going through her notes of the meeting. "I have something to tell you," he said. For some reason he had a feeling of discomfort in his stomach, though he had nothing to be nervous about.
"Go ahead." She turned a page in her notebook.
He hesitated, feeling he did not have her attention.
Natalya put down the book and smiled.
Now or never.
Dimka said: "Nina and I are engaged to be married."
Natalya went pale and her mouth dropped open in shock.
Dimka felt the need to say something else. "We told my family yesterday," he said. "At my grandfather's birthday party." Stop gabbling, shut up, he told himself. "He's seventy-four."
When Natalya spoke, her words shocked him. "What about me?" she said.
He hardly understood what she meant. "You?" he said.
Her voice dropped to a whisper. "We spent a night together."
"I'll never forget it." Dimka was baffled. "But afterward, all you would say to me was that you were married."
"I was scared."
"Of what?"
Her face showed genuine distress. Her wide mouth was twisted in a grimace, almost as if she were in pain. "Don't get married, please!"
"Why not?"
"Because I don't want you to."