Read Identical Page 22

Rage meant they were still

  alive,

  still feeling something. Now,

  since I know they’re definitely

  dead inside, I don’t want to

  listen to their ever-

  expanding

  list of unfinished rants and

  just-boiling-to-the-surface raves.

  (Not talking about the fun kind!)

  ’Cause once the bitch bus

  starts rolling, it’s practically

  unstoppable.

  Topping Today’s Rant List

  Is, of course, my dear grandmama.

  And guess who’s going to get

  ranted at. Spot on! It’s me.

  Daddy: Why didn’t you bother

  to tell me about my father’s call?

  I suppose I could deny knowing

  about it. But why lie? I shrug.

  “Guess I forgot. Sorry.”

  Mom: Sorry? That’s the best you can

  do? Under the circumstances…

  Patience was never my forte.

  “Under what circumstances?

  I don’t even know the man.”

  Daddy: Beside the point. You couldn’t

  tell the message was important?

  “The guy sounded like some sort of

  nut job. Anyway, why don’t I know

  him?” Way to flip the tables!

  Mom: Your father and I have reasons

  for the things we do or don’t allow.

  I hate her. She never lets her guard

  down and always has a ready answer.

  “So…is he a nut job, then?”

  Daddy, trying not to lose it:

  No, he’s not a fucking nut job.

  Not doing a good job of not losing

  it, Daddy, love. “Totally okay? Cool.

  Next time I’ll pick up and talk to him.”

  Mom, definitely losing it:

  Are you trying to make us angry?

  The game’s getting fun. Keep

  playing. Smile pretty. “Why

  would I want to do that, Mom?”

  Daddy, closer and closer to losing it:

  Extremely good question, I’d say.

  All of a sudden, I don’t want

  this to be a game anymore.

  I want answers. Honest ones.

  This Is a Rare Opportunity

  With Mom sitting right here,

  Daddy cannot so easily dismiss

  my questions. Valid questions.

  I look him directly in the eye—

  something I don’t often dare.

  “Why don’t you talk to your father?

  And why won’t you let him be a part

  of our lives?” Like anyone is a part

  of our lives. Including us. Truth is,

  there is no “our.” No “us.”

  Mom stares at Daddy, waiting.

  Doesn’t she know? Daddy glances

  back and forth between us, like a

  corralled coyote. Let’s just say he

  made my childhood extremely hard.

  If he thinks that’s communication,

  he should think again. Whose

  childhood isn’t hard? I shake

  my head. “Like how, Daddy?

  Can you be more specific?”

  His eyes glaze over, and I know

  he’s fallen into the past, a place

  he most definitely does not want

  to revisit. He exits quickly.

  I don’t want to talk about him.

  Surreal

  I swear, I’ve never

  seen Daddy look so shaken.

  So…wow. Scared.

  He looks like a little

  boy who has been sent to

  the principal’s office

  or to the woodshed

  to wait for a switching.

  I almost feel sorry

  for him, operative

  word being almost. Because

  the mold of his face

  reminds me intensely

  of Kaeleigh, when she knows

  he’s on his way to her.

  Like father, like son?

  One day I’ll get my answers.

  One day very soon.

  Meanwhile, Think I’ll Dive

  A little deeper into the shit pit.

  What have I got to lose?

  “If you won’t tell me about

  my grandfather, what about

  my grandmother? What’s all

  the hype about, anyway?”

  Daddy shifts gears to angry,

  jumps to his feet, stalks

  to the counter to refill his glass

  from the fifth of Turkey, drained

  half-dry since this morning.

  It’s not even dinnertime yet.

  I think he just might leave

  the room, highball in hand.

  Mom stops him with the weight

  of her voice. Don’t you dare

  walk away from her, Raymond.

  Tell her about your mother.

  She has the right to know.

  Daddy Takes a Gulp

  Of his whiskey, adds a big splash

  to the glass, rotates toward us

  on one heel. His expression

  is a curious mix of fury,

  resignation, and anguish.

  Finally he returns to the table.

  So you want to know about

  your grandmother? Fine.

  Let me tell you all about her.

  What I remember, anyway.

  I remember coming home

  from school and finding

  her passed out in front

  of the TV set, sweating

  cheap scotch and cigarettes….

  Holy crap! Déjà vu of the

  most unpleasant kind and

  he doesn’t seem to get it

  at all. Only difference

  is the choice of booze.

  I remember scrounging for

  my own dinner because I

  couldn’t shake her out

  of her stupor and my dear

  old dad worked swing shift.

  I remember other kids,

  laughing at my disgusting

  clothes. Mom was too

  fucked up to wash them

  and I was too little to try….

  All the while he talks,

  he sucks down Turkey,

  and it’s easy to imagine

  the scene, except for the dirty

  clothes. Daddy demands clean.

  I remember how excited

  my classmates got about

  bringing their parents

  to school plays. I prayed

  mine wouldn’t show up drunk.

  I remember working my ass

  off to bring home straight As

  and the day I finally did,

  my mother wasn’t home. In

  fact, she’d gone for good.

  That Was the Most

  My daddy has said to me in almost ten

  years. I can barely catch my breath,

  and he did all the talking. Still, I have

  questions. “Why did she leave?”

  He shrugs. She came limping back several

  years later, told me it was my father’s fault.

  Said he slept around. Like that was a good

  enough excuse for what her leaving did to me.

  Lots of people’s parents split up,

  especially over stuff like that. But…

  “Why didn’t she take you with her when

  she left?” What made him so cold?

  She said she thought my father would

  take better care of me. That she had no

  resources. That part, I’m sure, was true.

  But she never once checked on my welfare.

  There’s more to the story. A lot more.

  But it involves his father. He won’t share

  that part—the part I most need to know.
r />   The part about what makes Daddy tick.

  The Topic of Conversation

  Plunges him deeper into the depths

  of his bottle, and he disappears into

  his bathroom for a while. I know

  what he’s after in there. Oxy dessert,

  to chase his Wild Turkey main course.

  By the time Mom has dinner ready,

  Daddy has reached a state of oblivion.

  He will not share the table tonight.

  Which just leaves us girls. Kaeleigh

  watches Mom whip up a Hollandaise

  to go with the fresh fish entrée.

  She wants a daughter-mother talk

  about Ian, but I can’t figure out why.

  It would be a blistering day in Antarctica

  before I confessed any of my extracurricular

  activities. Think I’ll reroute the conversation.

  “So, Mom…” I drop my voice to just

  above a whisper. “Do you know what

  happened between Daddy and his father?”

  Does she know? If so, will she break

  down and tell us the necessary backstory?

  Mom pauses her whisking, but not for long.

  Sorry. He never told me the whole thing.

  Anyway, that will have to come from him.

  She Knows More, of Course

  But she won’t spill

  it tonight. Will we

  ever get the keys

  to this locked door?

  I want to scream.

  Curiosity strangles

  me until I choke out,

  “Was Daddy abused?”

  Mom opens the broiler,

  flips the fish. Finally

  she says, There are

  all kinds of abuse.

  This is the perfect

  opening, Kaeleigh,

  the way into asking

  for help. But no way.

  Kaeleigh doesn’t

  want to go there,

  doesn’t want to

  go anywhere near.

  Mom saves her

  the trouble. Okay.

  Dinner’s ready. Let’s

  open some wine.

  A Lot of Wine Later

  We are no closer to learning each

  other’s dark secrets, and much

  closer to our own states of stupor.

  Kaeleigh has already retreated,

  not a single word about Ian.

  No doubt a very wise decision.

  Tomorrow it’s back to the books

  (and, damn, a.m. history with

  Lawler) for me, back to party

  planning for Mom. The clock

  says ten forty-five. “Guess I’d

  better go to bed. It’s getting late.”

  She looks at me through chardonnay-

  lidded eyes. You look like her,

  you know. Very much so, in fact.

  What is she babbling about?

  My head feels wobbly, my

  tongue thick as pudding. “Who?”

  Your grandmother. I thought

  so when you were little, but

  it’s even more obvious now.

  I Stumble Off to Bed

  But find no comfort

  in its feathers and patchwork.

  Despite the wine and rich

  food, breaking down into calories,

  I feel cold, way deep inside,

  and it’s the kind of cold

  that can’t be fought

  with Hollandaise or alcohol

  or a pile of quilts. I wish I had

  a joint. A big, fat, stinky j to slide

  me into sleep. But no, all I

  can do is lie here, brain

  turning somersaults.

  It’s nights like

  these when memories

  stir, whipping themselves

  into stiff peaks of pain. Here

  comes one now, materializing

  like Daddy did that night.

  The night he came to

  Kaeleigh, crossed

  the final line.

  Mom Had Been Spending

  More and more time away

  from home. We were getting

  used to it. But that night,

  something was different.

  Kaeleigh and I lay in bed,

  listening to Daddy scream

  into the phone. What the fuck

  do you think you’re doing, Kay?

  It’s not just me you’re hurting.

  Come home. I’ll forgive you.

  We had no idea where she was,

  or what she was doing to make

  Daddy so mad. But whatever

  she said on the other end did not

  pacify him. The receiver slammed.

  The ensuing silence was scary,

  scarier than his yelling. In

  retrospect, I understand he had

  gone to visit his bottles. But he

  didn’t find enough healing there.

  His footsteps that night were

  soft. Hesitant. I think they even

  turned around. But eventually

  they came toward us again.

  The door opened slowly.

  Kaeleigh was used to Daddy’s

  visits, but that night she, too,

  felt something different in the air.

  Rage. Lust. Sorrow. Perversion.

  All mingled in Daddy’s sweat.

  There was nothing gentle

  about how he threw back

  the covers. Already naked,

  he pushed Kaeleigh roughly

  to one side, flopped beside her.

  I could tell she was afraid.

  This wasn’t her Daddy. This

  was a demon, his evil hard

  and sharp as a steel blade,

  ready to slice into her. It did.

  His attack was brutal, bloody,

  wordless except for a vicious

  Shut the fuck up at her pitiful

  scream, a plea to please, please

  no, Daddy, no. It hurts. Oh!

  I cowered, sick at the sight,

  but unable to divorce myself

  from the horror. I felt Kaeleigh’s

  pain. And when Daddy was done

  and she cried, I cried too.

  No Doubt About It

  There’s a demon inside him.

  Demons, they say, are fallen

  angels. The real question is,

  who pushed Daddy over

  the edge,

  into the abyss? I’d say there

  are several likely candidates.

  And, oh awesome. I’m related

  to all of them, heiress

  of darkness.

  Dark or not, though, I want

  to know them. Want to know

  exactly what created not only

  Daddy, but through him, me.

  Is

  that so much to ask? We’re

  probably too damaged to ever

  be fixable, but if there’s even

  a tiny chance, I need to know

  where

  to find it. In Daddy? Ha. In

  Mom? Unlikely. In some guy?

  Every single one I know is worse

  off than me. My only hope

  is to ferret out exactly who

  I am.

  Kaeleigh

  I Can Hardly Wait

  To get to school today,

  something totally new, and

  all because of Ian. He takes

  the edge

  off my pain. In fact, for once

  I don’t feel like fighting pain

  with food. For once, I feel

  like I might crawl beyond this place

  of darkness,

  the place I’ve called home

  for as long as I can remember.

  I jump out of bed, start to dress,

  and my bubble of optimism

  is

  b
urst almost immediately.

  Down the hall, Mom and Daddy

  are into it already, scratching

  at each other like alley cats.

  Where

  did their own love go? Why

  did it have to die and suck me

  down into its shallow grave?

  Guess I’ll go shave my legs,

  then scope out the pantry.

  I am

  famished, after all.

  I Am on My Third Bowl of Cereal

  When Daddy comes into the kitchen.

  His eyes wear “pissed” and when they

  fall to my mouth, stuffed with Shredded

  Wheat, irritation grows to outrage.

  What the hell are you doing?

  He can’t know how many bowls

  I’ve downed, and I haven’t made

  a mess of the table. I swallow a major

  mouthful. “What do you mean, Daddy?”

  You look like a regular pig.

  Good. I’m glad he thinks I look

  like a pig. Still, his words sting

  and my eyes start to water.

  “I’m just having some cereal.”

  Ladies don’t stuff their mouths full.

  I’m not a lady and don’t want to

  be, but Daddy’s spoiling to fight

  with someone weaker than Mom.

  “Sorry. I won’t do it again.”

  That’s more like it. Now give me a kiss.