None of them had any sympathy for the left-wing, if not revolutionary, nature of republican Spain, and certainly in the early days, they would have preferred a rapid nationalist success rather than what they saw as a slide towards the horrors of bolshevism. But their principal concerns lay elsewhere. They no more wanted Spain to be controlled by Nazi Germany or fascist Italy, Britain’s chief rival in the Mediterranean, than for the country to fall under Soviet influence. Above all, they were deeply concerned that the Spanish conflagration would prove to be another Sarajevo, creating a widening ripple of involvement which would turn into the next European war. The British Foreign Office was nevertheless totally wrong to assume the lofty role of international policeman when it was secretly prepared to sacrifice the Spanish people, just as it sacrificed the Czechs in 1938.
One must also look at the effective results of the non-intervention policy, which prevented the Republic from purchasing arms openly. The republicans’ greatest needs were for aircraft, tanks and automatic weapons. French equipment was generally of poor quality and the British aircraft available at that date were obsolete. Probably the only country capable of satisfying their needs, apart from the Soviet Union, was the United States. Roosevelt and Cordell Hull may have been influenced by the non-intervention agreement, but it was the Catholic lobby that led Congress to block arms supplies to the Republic. Thus, apart from a few aircraft purchases, Mexican rifles and ammunition, and Czechoslovakian machine-guns bought privately, it might appear that, even without the Non-Intervention Committee the Republic had no alternative to the Soviet monopoly of arms supplies. Nevertheless, the decision to send Stalin the Republic’s gold reserves was one of the most critical of the war.
The archbishop of Burgos, who justified the cruelty of the war as being ultimately less cruel because it meant a shorter conflict, was clearly wrong, both morally and logically. Neither side could be terrified into submission. The polarization of political beliefs meant that both parties felt that everything in which they believed, as well as their very existence, was at stake. This transmuted fear into desperate bravery. The war was only likely to end when a decisive lack of troops, armaments and munitions demonstrated that defeat was inescapable. This came about for the Republic after its catastrophic defeat on the Ebro.
The only possible reason for continuing the struggle would have been to achieve better surrender terms from Franco, but this was a vain hope. Negrín failed utterly with his thirteen points and there were no grounds to expect that Franco was likely to shift his position; in fact, he was bound to become even more inflexible the closer he came to victory. Any decision to fight on could lead only to a useless loss of life. An International Brigader wrote later, ‘It was all very fine for the left in Europe and America to beat their breasts and demand that the common people of Spain should fight to the last man, but once it had become apparent that the war could not be won it should have been terminated.’4 Whether or not an earlier surrender might have mitigated the vicious revenge of the victors is impossible to say, but it is doubtful. All one can be sure of is that it would have saved many of the tens of thousands of lives lost in the hopeless battle for Catalonia.
Little more need be said about the Franquist vengeance, a process which was frequently justified on the basis of sentences for ‘military rebellion’, a reversal of judicial logic that speaks for itself. Facts gathered so painstakingly by Spanish historians over recent years leave little further doubt about its scale or its cruelty. The only question left to answer covers the thought processes of those who perpetrated such a regime. But to speculate about the mental state of such oppressors, whether Nazi, Soviet or nationalist, is to risk assuming the dubious mantle of a long-distance psychiatrist.
The repression extended throughout the population as a whole, creating a terrible claustrophobia, exceeded only by the harshness of living conditions imposed by the regime. One of the great debates of recent years has been the degree to which Franco’s policy of autarchy and centralized financial direction laid the ground for Spain’s subsequent economic transformation. The argument for the economic policy established under Franco is very hard to fathom since it created a deadening form of state control which some commentators have compared to the Soviet satellite states of the Cold War years. In the case of Franco’s Spain, however, the degree of corruption and waste was perhaps equalled only by Ceauşescu’s Romania. The partial economic liberalization which came about in the 1960s was in many ways more a case of accident due to foreign influences than of design.
The pertinent question, however, is what would a republican victory have produced? If the People’s Army had achieved victory in, say, 1937 or 1938, what form of government would have ensued–the left-liberal administration of early 1936 or a hard-line communist regime? The accelerated collapse of the republican government in the spring and summer of 1936 and the onset of civil war, which triggered the revolutionary upheaval, followed a different path from the chaos that ensued from the First World War. Yet there was one similarity to the Russian revolution: this was the communist determination to eliminate their left-wing allies once the war had been won against the right. In September 1936, soon after his arrival, General Vladimir Goriev reported to Moscow: ‘A struggle against the anarchists is absolutely inevitable after victory over the whites. This struggle will be very severe.’5 André Marty, the Comintern representative, stated on 10 October, ‘After victory we will get even with them [the anarchists], all the more so since at that point we will have a strong army.’6 And Pravda declared on 10 December that the ‘cleaning up of Trotskyist and anarcho-syndicalist elements will be carried out with the same energy as in the USSR.’ As numerous reports back to Moscow made clear, the Popular Front strategy was merely a strategy ‘for the moment’. The Comintern representatives in Spain were clearly seeking communist hegemony in Spain and, even though this was not in line with Stalin’s general strategy, it is significant that no reproof or warning about this from Dimitrov appears in the communications between Moscow and Spain.
Stalinists, by the very nature of their own ideology, were not prepared to share power with anybody else in the longer term. Only one factor was likely to mitigate this in Spain, and that was the question of the Soviet Union’s interests elsewhere on the international stage. Stalin had already demonstrated his readiness to sacrifice a foreign communist party if it happened to be in the interests of the ‘Socialist Motherland’. In the case of Spain, it was mainly events in central Europe which determined Soviet policy. The British appeasement of Hitler in 1938 over his demands on Czechoslovakia prompted Stalin to prepare a new course, even if that eventually meant an alliance with Hitler himself. The post-war years would have been desperate, whatever government was in power. But everything afterwards would have depended on the form of regime which emerged. A fully democratic government would presumably have received Marshall Plan aid from the United States in 1948. Then, with a reasonably unfettered economy, recovery would almost certainly have begun by 1950, like elsewhere in Western Europe. But with an authoritarian leftist, perhaps overtly communist, government, Spain would probably have been left in a similar state to those Central European or Balkan people’s republics until after 1989.
The Spanish Civil War is, however, best remembered in entirely human terms: the clash of beliefs, the ferocity, the generosity and selfishness, the hypocrisy of diplomats and ministers, the betrayal of ideals and political manoeuvres and, above all, the bravery and self-sacrifice of those who fought on both sides. But history, which is never tidy, must always end with questions. Conclusions are much too convenient.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abad de Santillán, Diego, Porqué perdimos la guerra, Buenos Aires, 1940——, Memorias, 1897–1936, Barcelona, 1977
Abella, Rafael, La Vida Cotidiana durante la Guerra Civil, 2 vols, Barcelona, 1978
Abellán, José Luis (ed.), El exilio español de 1939, 6 vols, Madrid, 1976–8——, Historia crítica del pensamiento español, 2 vols, Madrid, 19
88
Acosta, Gonzalo, et al., El canal de los presos. Trabajos forzados: de la represión poltica a la explotación económica, Barcelona, 2004
Aguilar Fernández, Paloma, Memoria y olvido de la guerra civil, Madrid, 1996
Akin, Mohammed Ibn A., La actitud de los moros ante el Alzamiento, Málaga, 1997
Alba, Victor, Histoire du POUM. Le marxisme en Espagne (1919–1939), Paris, 1975
Alcalá Zamora, Niceto, Memorias, Barcelona, 1977
Alexander, Bill, British Volunteers for Liberty. Spain 1936–1939, London, 1982 ‘Alfredo’, see Togliatti, Palmiro
Alpert, Michael, El ejército republicano en la guerra civil, Paris, 1977——, La reforma militar de Azaña: 1931–1933, Madrid, 1982——, La guerra civil española en el March, Madrid, 1987
Alted, Alicia, ‘Los niños de la guerra civil’ in Anales de Historia Contemporánea, 2003
Álvarez, Santiago, Negrín, personalidad histórica, Madrid, 1994
Álvarez del Vayo, Julio, Freedom’s Battle, London, 1940; En la lucha, México, 1974
Álvarez Rodriguez and López Ortega, R. (eds), Poesía anglo-norteamericana de la guerra civil española, Salamanca, 1986
Araquistáin, Luis, El comunisino y la guerra de España, Carmaux, 1939
Arasa, Daniel, La invasión de los maquis, Barcelona, 2004
Aróstegui, Julio (ed.), Historia y memoria de la Guerra Civil. Encuentro de Castilla y León, 3 vols, Valladolid, 1988——, ‘Violencia y politica en España’ in Ayer, 13, Madrid, 1994
Aróstegui, Julio and Martínez, J. A., La Junta de Defensa de Madrid, Madrid, 1984
Asociación de Historia Contemporánea, ‘La Guerra Civil’, Ayer, 50, Madrid, 2003
Atholl, Katherine Duchess of, Searchlight on Spain, Harmondsworth, 1938
Atkin, Nicholas and Tallett, F., Priests, Prelates and People, London, 2003
Azaña, Manuel, Causas de la guerra de España, Barcelona, 1986 ——, Diarios completos. Monarquía, República, Guerra Civil, Barcelona, 2000, ——, Discursos políticos, Barcelona, 2003
Azcárate, Pablo de, Mi embajada en Londres durante la guerra civil española, Barcelona, 1976
Aznar, Manuel, Historia militar de la guerra civil de España, Madrid, 1940 ——, Pensamiento literario y compromiso antifascista de la intelligencia española republicana, Barcelona, 1978
Bachoud, André, Los españoles ante las campañas de Marruecos, Madrid, 1988——, Franco, Barcelona, 2000
Bahamonde, Angel and Cervera, J., Así terminó la guerra de España, Madrid, 1999
Bahamonde, Antonio, Un año con Queipo. Memorias de un nacionalista, Barcelona, 1938
Balfour, S. and Preston, Paul, España y las grandes potencias en el siglo XX, Barcelona, 2002
Banc, Ivo (ed.), The Diary of Georgi Dimitrov, 1933–1949, New Haven, 2003
Barciela, Carlos (ed.), Autarquía y mercado negro, Barcelona, 2003
Barea, Arturo, La forja de un rebelde, Madrid, 2000
Ben-Ami, Shlomo, Los orígenes de la Segunda República, Madrid, 1990
Benet, Josep, Catalunya sota el re`gim franquista, Paris, 1973
Bennassar, Bartolomé, La guerre d’Espagne et ses lendemains, Paris, 2004
Benson, F. R., Writers in Arms, London, 1968Berdah, Jean-François, La democracia asesinada: España 1931–1939. La República española y las grandes potencias, Barcelona, 2002
Bernal, Antonio Miguel, Economía e historia de los latifundios, Madrid, 1988
Bernanos, Georges, Les grandes cimetie`res sous la Lune, Paris, 1938
Bernecker, Walter L., Colectividades y revolución social. El anarquismo en la guerra civil española, 1936–1939, Barcelona, 1983
Bessie, Alvah, Men in Battle: A History of Americans in Spain, New York, 1939
Blanco Escolá, Carlos, La incompetencia militar de Franco, Madrid, 2000——, Vicente Rojo, el general que humilló a Franco, Barcelona, 2003 ——, Falacias de la guerra civil. Un homenaje a la cause republicana, Barcelona, 2005
Blaye, Eduardo de, Franco ou la Monarchie sans Roi, Paris, 1974
Blinkhorn, Martín, Aragón en la revolución española, Barcelona, 1983
Bolín, Luis, Spain: The Vital Years, London, 1967; Los años vitales, Madrid, 1967
Bolloten, Burnett, The Spanish Revolution: The Left and the Struggle for Power, London, 1979 and Barcelona, 1980
Bonamusa, Francesc, ‘L’administració de Justicia a Catalunya de setembre a desembre de 1936’in Recerques, 4, Barcelona, 1974——, Andreu Nin y el movimiento comunista en España, 1930–1937, Barcelona, 1977——, Política i finances republicanes, 1931–1939, Tarragona, 1997
Borkenau, Franz, The Spanish Cockpit, London, 1937; Ann Arbor, 1963
Bosch, Aurora, Ugetistas y libertarios. Guerra civil y revoluciónenelpaís Valenciano, Valencia, 1983
Bosch Gimpera, Pere, Memòries, Barcelona, 1980
Bowers, Claude, My Mission to Spain, New York, 1954; Misión en España, Barcelona, 1977
Boyarsky, V. I., Partizansvo vchera, segodnya, zavtra, Moscow, 2003
Bozal, Valeriano, Pintura y escultura española del siglo XX, 2 vols, Madrid, 1991
Brademas, John, Anarcosindicalismo y revolución en España, Barcelona, 1974
Brenan, Gerald, The Spanish Labyrinth, Cambridge, 1969; El laberinto español, Paris, 1962
Bricall, Josep María, La política económica de la Generalitat (1936–1939) 2 vols Barcelona, 1979
Broué, Pierre and Témime, E., La Révolution et la guerre d’Espagne, Paris, 1961
Brown, C. G., El siglo XX. Del 98 a la guerra civil, Barcelona, 1993
Brusco, Ramón, Les milícies antifeixiste i l’Exèrcit popular a Catalunya (1936–1937), Lérida, 2003
Buckley, Henry, Vida y muerte de la República española, Madrid, 2004
Bullejos, José, La Comintern en España. Recuerdos de mi vida, México, 1972
Bullón de Mendoza and Álvaro de Diego, Historias orales de la guerra civil, Barcelona, 2000
Busquets, Julio, El Militar de Carrera en España, Barcelona, 1971
Busquets, Julio and Losada J. C., Ruido de sables. Las conspiraciones militares en la España del siglo XX, Barcelona, 2003
Cabanellas, Guillermo, La guerra de los mil días, Barcelona, 1973
Cabrera, Mercedes, La patronal ante la II Repu ´blica Organizaciónes y estrategia, 1931–1936, Madrid, 1983——, Con luz y taquígrafos, Madrid, 1999
Cabrera, Mercedes and Del Rey, F., El poder de los empresarios. Política e intereses Económicos en la España contemporánea, 1875–2000, Madrid, 2002
Cabrera Castillo, F., Del Ebro a Gandesa. La batalla del Ebro, Madrid, 2002
Callahan, William J., La Iglesia católica en España, 1875–2002, Barcelona, 2002
Cambó, Francesc, Memorias (1876–1936), Madrid, 1987
Caminal, Miguel, Joan Comorera. Catalanisme i socialisme, 1913–1936, Barcelona, 1984——, Joan Comorera: Guerra i revolució, 1936–1939, Barcelona, 1985
Campbell, Roy, Light on a Dark Horse, London, 1951
Canales, Antonio F., La llarga posguerra, Barcelona, 1997
Capponi, N., I legionari rossi. Le Brigate Internazionali nella Guerra civile spagnola (1936–1939), Rome, 2000
Carbajosa, Mónica y Pablo, La corte literaria de José Antonio, Barcelona, 2003
Cárcel Orti, Vicente, La gran persecución. España 1936–1939, Barcelona, 2001——, Breve historia de la Iglesia en España, Barcelona, 2003
Cardona, Gabriel, El poder militar y la España contemporánea hasta la guerra civil, Madrid, 1983——, El gigante descalzo: El ejército de Franco, Madrid, 2003
Cardona, Gabriel and Losada, J. C., Aunque me tires el Puente, Madrid, 2004
Carnero, Teresa (ed.), El reinado de Alfonso XIII, Madrid, 1997
Carr, Raymond, Spain 1808–1939, Oxford, 1968——, Estudios sobre la República y la guerra civil española, Barcelona, 1973——, España 1808–1975, Barcelona, 1984
Carreras, Albert and Tafunell, X., Historia económi
ca de la España contempora Barcelona, 2004
Carrion, Pascual, La reforma agraria de la Segunda República y la situación actual de la agricultura español, Barcelona, 1973
Carroll, Peter N., The Odyssey of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade: Americans in the Spanish Civil War, Stanford, 1998
Carulla, Jordi and Carulla, A., La guerra civil en 2000 carteles, Barcelona, 1997
Casado, Segismundo, The Last Days of Madrid, London, 1939; Así cayó Madrid, Madrid, 1968
Casanova, Julián, Anarquismo y revolución social en la sociedad rural aragonesa (1936–1938), Madrid, 1985——, De la calle al frente. El anarcosindicalismo en España(1931–1939), Barcelona, 1997
Casanova, Julián, et al., Morir, matar, sobrevivir. La violencia en la dictadura de Franco, Barcelona, 2002
Casares, Maria, Residente Privilégiée, Paris, 1980
Castells, Andreu, Las Brigadas Internacionales en la Guerra de España, Barcelona 1974
Castro, Luis, Burgos durante la guerra civil (in preparation)
Castro Delgado, Enrique, Hombres made in Moscú, Barcelona, 1965
Cattell, David T., Communism and the Spanish Civil War, New York, 1965
Cenarro, Ángela, La sonrisa de Falange, Barcelona, 2005
Cervera, Javier, Madrid en Guerra. La ciudad clandestina 1936–1939, Madrid, 1998
Chalmers-Mitchell, Peter, My House in Malaga, London, 1938
Chapaprieta, Joaquín, La paz fue possible, Barcelona, 1971
Chaves, Julián, La guerra civil en Extremadura, Badajoz, 1997
Chomsky, Noam, American Power and the New Mandarins, New York, 1969
Churchill, Winston, Step by Step, 1936–1939, London, 1939
Ciano, Galeazzo, Diarios, 1937–1943, Barcelona, 2004
Cierva, R. de la, Historia actualizada de la Segunda repu ´blica y la guerra civil, 1931–1939, Madrid, 2003