“The new moon came, and the king sat down to partake of the festive meal. He took his usual seat, back to the wall. Ever since his madness took hold, he had insisted on always sitting with his face to the door, so that he would be prepared for any enemy that might come upon him. Yonatan rose then, and gave up his seat so that Avner could sit by the king’s right side. He came and sat by me, at one of the lower tables. But the seat to his left, David’s place, remained empty. Father did not at first remark on it. Then he leaned over to Avner. He pointed to me. From my father’s lewd gestures and Avner’s awkward, forced laughter, I could tell the king was making some ribald joke about David’s lack of continence. Because it was a ritual meal, impurity prevented participation. My father assumed that David was absent for the commonplace cause: an untimely emission of his seed.
“But by sundown, when the law states that purity is restored, David still had not come. My father looked with annoyance at David’s vacant seat. ‘Why hasn’t the son of Yishai come to the meal?’ he asked loudly. A hush fell over the room, the scraping of platters, the chatter all falling silent. Everyone sensed the change of mood. I caught my breath. That he would not speak David’s name was a sign of ill temper. I opened my mouth to speak up, but Yonatan drew a brow to hush me. Instead, he raised his voice and addressed our father. ‘David begged leave to go to Beit Lehem. He asked it as a particular favor: “Please let me go,” he said, “for we are going to have a family feast and my eldest brother has summoned me to it. Let me slip away and see my kinsmen.” So he said, and so I agreed. That is why he has not come to the king’s table.’
“My father rose suddenly to his full, intimidating height, knocking his goblet to the floor. He strode across the room to where Yonatan sat by me. Yonatan was scrambling to his feet but he wasn’t quick enough. The king pulled him up by his tunic. ‘You son of a faithless whore! I know you side with the son of Yishai—to your shame, and the shame of the cunt that bore you. For as long as the son of Yishai lives on earth, neither you nor your kingship will be secure. Now, then, remember who you are. Have him brought to me, for he is marked for death.’
“I was cowering, in fear for my brother. ‘Don’t answer him!’ I hissed. ‘He’s not in his right mind.’ But Yonatan was too enraged to hear me. His face was twisted and dark. Instead of pulling away from my father he took a step toward him. ‘Why should he be put to death? What has he done?’ The king grasped a spear then, and brought the point upward, right beneath Yonatan’s chin. ‘Don’t!’ I cried, reaching out to grab his spear arm. He did not even turn in my direction, but he brought his arm back and slapped my face with such force I went sprawling. I felt a sharp pain where my body hit the edge of the table. I gulped for breath. The broken edge of a rib ground against flesh. I slid to the floor. Yonatan stood there, eye to eye with our father, as the fallen goblet rocked back and forth on its rim. You could feel their rage like a solid form between them. No one else moved. Then, without taking his eyes off my father’s face, Yonatan reached down and pulled me to my feet. Grasping me firmly by the wrist, he strode from the room, dragging me after him. He saw me safely to my house, set two of his loyal men to guard me, and went off to the agreed meeting place, where he delivered to David the news that the rift with our father was lethal. Later, when he told me about it, he said that they kissed each other and wept together, and that David wept the longer.
“My father took his revenge before Yonatan returned. The bruises on my face were still purple and yellow when my father had me married off to Palti. It was a brilliant act of vengeance, designed to punish me and humiliate David. I wept and keened all through the wedding, and screamed all through the bedding that followed it, and not only because Palti’s hard body pounded on my broken rib. I didn’t need to be put in physical agony to know I was being raped. Palti was drunk from the wedding feast and he apologized, after. He said he had consummated the marriage because the king ordered it done; he said he would not come to me again without my consent. I said I could never consent to be an adulteress, for so I thought myself.
“But in time, as you know, I changed toward him. We went off to live in his house in the hills, and he was kind and patient toward me, and saw to my comfort and kept his word. It was a peaceful house, such as I had never known. And when Yonatan finally came to see me, he was full of terrible news. You know what David did; I don’t need to recite it to you. The lies, the betrayals . . .”
I knew that she was no longer talking only of personal matters. David’s behavior when he left Shaul’s court had been desperate and reprehensible. He committed theft, sacrilege and, maybe, even treachery. His actions and his lies brought death and terror upon innocent people.
“I didn’t know what had happened till Yonatan finally saw fit to tell me,” she said. “All I knew was that David had left me in the hands of my father when I was injured and defenseless. I knew he fled with no food and no weapon. To provision himself, Yonatan told me, David stopped at the shrine of Nov, which stood about halfway between our home and his family beit av in Beit Lehem. His great trophy, the sword of the giant of Gath, was kept at the shrine, wrapped in an oilcloth, concealed behind the ephod. He knew that, of course. That’s probably why he risked stopping there. The priest greeted him, somewhat surprised to see Shaul’s top captain traveling alone and unarmed. David lied, and told the priest that he was on a secret mission for the king, and that his troops were encamped nearby. He said they lacked supplies, and asked for the shrine’s consecrated bread with which to feed his men. He took the sword of course. And you know what came of it . . .”
It was a heinous business. Shaul, in his madness, believed the priests of the shrine had betrayed him by feeding and arming David. He would not accept the true account—that they had no knowledge that David was an outlaw; that they had no reason to doubt that he was serving the king as his son-in-law and most trusted servant. Shaul sentenced them all to die. But no soldier of the Land would carry out these sacrilegious murders. It fell to an Edomite, who followed other gods, to kill all of them. The refusal of his men to do his bidding further fueled Shaul’s rage, and he ordered the whole town of Nov sacked. He put his soldiers in such fear for their own lives that this time, alas, the men obeyed him. They killed everyone in that town—women, babes, the frail elderly.
She had fallen silent, gazing blankly.
“Do you need wine?” I asked her. “You are very pale.”
“Am I? So was Yonatan, that day, when he finally girded himself to come and face me in my misery. I was half mad with not knowing, full of hurt and anger that my brother—my protector—hadn’t been with me, hadn’t saved me. And then, when he came, at last, he was civil to Palti, but he could barely look at me. I could read the disgust in his eyes. I could see he was fighting himself to be just to me, not to blame me for the fact that I’d been whored, that I was dishonored.”
“Surely not,” I blurted. I thought of Yonatan as I had briefly known him; a man so loyal that he risked his life to bring David the intelligence that would ensure his safety. Such a man could not at the same time be disloyal to a beloved sister who had been wronged and was innocent.
She gave a grim laugh. “Even you, Natan, must know what men are, when it comes to matters of sex and honor. I was his sister, and what fouled my honor fouled his. So my father’s sick revenge worked its poison, even between Yonatan and me.
“As distraught as I was at his coldness, I could tell from his face that dreadful things had happened. Finally, I demanded that he tell me what he knew. He unfolded the whole of it—the massacre at Nov, the flight to Gath, everything. And even as he spoke, I could see him struggling to cast it all in his own mind as necessary and forgivable, one more tragedy of our father’s madness. Oh, yes. He laid it all there, on our father’s wretched malady. I suppose he had to fashion it thus, so as to be able to forgive David, whose rash and selfish acts caused such mayhem. I suppose it was just one more offering to the great love
they bore each other: that even such grave sins and acts of treachery could be forgiven. Of course, he told me that David greatly lamented the deaths, and took full blame. As if that were enough to absolve the butchery of holy men and their families, the ruined homes and the burned fields. Forgiveness aplenty, yet none for me. None for his sister, who was nothing but a victim.
“But I, who had been less loved, was less able to be forgiving. And of course he brought news of another betrayal. A more intimate one. I’m speaking of the marriage to Ahinoam. I’d been broken enough, but this news flayed me. Yonatan tried to explain it away, to give me a way to bear it. David cared nothing for this girl, he claimed. She was little more than a pretty simpleton, a healthy peasant girl who would go uncomplaining with him into the wilderness, tolerate hardship and make no demands upon him. It was simply necessary for him to get an heir. It was any man’s duty to do this; much more so a man destined to be king. Furthermore, he could not wait until he was reunited with me, for no one could say when that might be. He had to get an heir while he was young enough to protect and raise the child. David’s life was full of perils; I must not blame him for wanting to make a son. My own future son would of course take precedence over any child of this nobody Ahinoam, should she be brought to bed of a boy. Indeed, Yonatan assured me, David longed for me, for our reunion, for the chance for us to have our own son. So he spoke, and so I tried to believe, as I lay in my cold bed, while Palti knocked fruitlessly upon the door and I sent him, unsatisfied, away.
“And then, as you know well, David married Avigail of Carmel, the widow of Navaal. Palti made sure I heard of it. When finally I got a chance to confront Yonatan, he confessed the truth of it, and was honest enough to confirm what Palti had told me, that this time it was a match of affection and mutual regard. I think my brother saw, by then, that I was wasting away in Palti’s house, pining for a future that might never be, estranging myself from the one man who could give me happiness in the present. So, in stages, my faith wavered. I began to believe that David had not loved me at all. I began to look at Palti for the man he was: a good man, kind and just. And as I looked at him, I would see him looking at me hungrily, as if he really desired me. Me. I had not been desired in that way before. In the end, I gave way to it, and I fell in love with him. And then you all fled to Ziklag, to the enemy king, or so we thought. Yonatan could no longer bring me any news or word from David. I began to will myself to forget him. There were days, weeks, when I did not think of him at all. And when my children came, finally he became just a bitter memory, without, as I thought—wrongly, of course—any power to wound me at all. Then when the news came from Har HaGilboa—”
She stopped. I glanced up from my writing. Her eyes brimmed and her chin quivered. I looked at her, and what I saw was David’s face, grief-blasted, the day that same news came to us, in our Ziklag exile, that the battle on the mountain of Gilboa had been lost. That Shaul and Yonatan were among the many dead.
“No more,” I said, putting down my reed. “No need.”
She gave a ragged sigh. The tears were spilling down her face now. She reached out a hand and laid it on my arm. “Thank you. You . . . you are kind. I’m not used to it.”
I blew on the parchments to dry the ink, then I rose. I bowed to her and turned, reaching for the door latch.
“Natan—will you tell the king I did as he commanded?”
“I will,” I said. “I will tell him you fulfilled his request in full measure.” As I stepped through the door, she spoke again.
“Natan?”
“Yes?”
“Will you—” Her voice broke. She took a breath, composing herself. “Will you remember me to him?”
I left her in that dismal little cell, and crept away. I had gone there expecting a difficult interrogation with a woman animated by hatred. I had prepared myself to deal with a refractory silence or to withstand an outpouring of bile. I had not expected to be overwhelmed with pity.
All women’s lives are like that, I told myself, as I climbed the stair that led to the better-appointed rooms of the king’s house. Which of them ever is mistress of her own destiny? Highborn or peasant, it makes no difference. At least David hadn’t had her flogged or killed, as another king might have done.
But now that I had heard the tale of her life in her own words, my heart ached for her. I didn’t need to make her relive the events that led to the rift with David. I knew all about it. I was there.
IX
I sat in the buttery light of the late evening, lingering over my wine. Outside, finches and larks tousled the trees, singing their frantic hymn to the waning day. Craving solitude, I sent Muwat out, offering him an evening of liberty. He went reluctantly, his young face anxious. I imagine I looked rather ill, if my outer self gave a true reflection of my low spirits. I poured more wine, letting the light find fire in the liquid as it streamed from the jar into the cup. It was good wine, from the king’s own store. My father would have valued the skill of the winemaker. I thought of our vineyards, the green vines scribbling across the steep russet hills that sprang up from the flat white shore. I could recall every crevice and cave, every rough tree trunk, every dusty leaf, the sudden pulses of fresh springwater through tumbles of stone. I felt a stab of longing for the apricot-colored earth of those vineyards, for my father, rubbing it in his coarse hands, tasting it, assessing as it crumbled, not too sticky nor too fine, but just the correct tilth to support the roots and sustain the vines. All that skill, lost with the plunge of metal. His blood, soaking into the soil. Even in death, nourishing that earth he had loved and tended. Had his death really been necessary, as David had asserted, and I, a child, had so readily accepted? I pushed the thought away. Doubt was like rot. Excise it at the first speckling, the first stain, the first faint stench of decay. But then—I suppose because my mind was on the wine—I thought of that other kind of rot, the soft gray fungus that sometimes afflicts the late grape harvest if the air turns unexpectedly moist. That rot causes the grapes to yield up a heavy, viscous juice of stupendously rich flavor. The wine pressed from such grapes was the best of all. Maybe doubt was like that sometimes. Maybe it, too, could yield rich fruit. Perhaps, then, it was right to doubt. Perhaps I had a right to doubt.
But this line of thinking could bring me no ease. I did not want to collapse again, as I had that day, killing for Achish in the Amalekite village when thoughts of my father had overcome me. I had learned to live my life in the grip of an iron-fisted discipline. For a man like me, self-mastery was everything. I exercised that discipline, swilled the fine wine, and willed my thoughts elsewhere, to a part of the Land I had never seen.
Har HaGilboa, that spinelike ridge that looms over the Wadi Yezreel. They say it is lovely there at this time of year, the wild iris all abloom, the thorn breaks full of the music of migrating birds, the cold white tip of Har Hermon visible in the distant north. We never got that far, of course. We marched out of Ziklag and joined with the forces of Achish, the army of Gath. Our men were in mixed spirits. Some, who had been ill treated by Shaul, carried a yearning for vengeance and were spoiling for this fight—a clean fight of army against army instead of the mean skirmishing that others as well as I found dishonorable. But for some of our men, the idea of joining forces against our people was gut-wrenching. Their enmity was toward Shaul himself, not toward our people as a whole, and only their loyalty to David drove them forward.
So, we marched under Achish’s banners all the way from Gath north up to Shunem, which was the staging area for the Plishtim armies. It was dark when we arrived, but even so, it was clear that the forces mustering comprised a mighty host. We made a hasty camp, and David called me into his tent. Yoav and Avishai were already there. David had drawn a map of the dispositions, as he had understood them, in the dust at his feet. “It’s clear what Shaul means to do,” he said, tapping the point of his spear on the lines that represented the position of Shaul’s forces across t
he wadi on Gilboa. “He means to attack head-on. He thinks having the high ground gives him an advantage. But he’s underestimated the Plishtim forces. The only chance, against these numbers, is to let them overrun the Wadi Yezreel. Let them think they’ve won. Then surround them by night and sweep in from the rear, here”—he prodded the dirt—“and the flanks, here”—he swept the spear point in a wide arc. “What’s wrong with him? He must have sent out spies to assess the forces, and if so he must know a frontal assault is madness.”
“Well, you said it,” Yoav rumbled. “As if we needed more proof of madness.”
What I noticed was that David had used “them” to refer to the army of which we were purportedly members. It seemed a strange thing to me at the time. Between that, the hard ground and the normal wakefulness on the march to battle, I got little sleep that night.
I rose at first light, and made my way through the stirring camp. All the serens from the coastal cities had answered the call to arms, their diverse banners snapping in the stiff breeze. I walked up the rise to survey the totality of the encampment. I had never seen such an army.
By the time I returned to our tents, David was in conference with Achish and several other Plishtim leaders—serens, by their elaborate armor and the circlets on their helmets. Even from far off, I could see that the debate was heated. As I moved forward to hear better, one raised his voice and extended an accusing arm at David. “This man is our enemy. I will not go into battle with him, or with his men. They’ll cut us down and betray us.”
Achish answered in a low, steady voice, and from where I stood, I could not make out his words. Whatever he said, it must have been unconvincing. One of the serens pulled off his helmet and threw it at Achish’s feet, cursing in his own tongue. I saw Achish turn to David, laying his hands on both his shoulders. After a few moments, David bowed, turned to each of the serens and saluted them, then turned away, calling out for Yoav.