In the first, Josef is a young boy; in the second, he's a man. The quality of both photos is shoddy at best. "I can't tell. But does it really matter? I mean, if all the other stuff he's said fits?"
"Well," Leo answers, "that depends. In 1981 the Supreme Court concluded that anyone who was a guard at a Nazi concentration camp took part in supporting the activities that occurred there--including murder, if we're talking about Auschwitz Two. The court's analysis was reminiscent of a trial in Germany years earlier in which a suspect said that if German authorities prosecuted him, they should prosecute everyone at the camp, because the camp operated as a chain of functions and everyone in that chain had to perform his function, or the whole apparatus of annihilation would have ground to a halt. So everyone from the guards to the bean counters at Auschwitz is culpable for what happened there, simply because they were aware of what was going on inside its fences, and performed their duties. Think about it like this--let's say you and your boyfriend decide to kill me in my office. The deal is that your boyfriend is going to chase me around the room with a knife while you stand outside holding the door closed so I can't escape. Both of you are going down for Murder One. It's just a division of labor about how you each participated."
"I don't have a boyfriend," I blurt out. It turns out that it is easier to say aloud than I would have expected, and instead of feeling as if my heart has been ripped out of my chest, it seems as if I am made of helium. "I mean, I did, but things aren't . . ." I shrug. "Anyway. He won't be killing you in your office anytime soon."
Leo blushes. "Guess that means I'll be able to sleep well tonight."
I clear my throat. "So all we have to do is prove that Josef worked at Auschwitz," I say. "If he's confessed to that, isn't it enough?"
"That depends on how trustworthy his confession is."
"Why would any court think he'd lie about that?"
"Why does anyone lie?" Leo says. "He's old. He's got mental issues. He's a masochist. Who knows? For all we know, he wasn't even there. He could have read a book and regurgitated that history to you; that doesn't mean it's his own."
"Even though you have a file with his name on it?"
"He's already given you one false name," Leo points out. "This could be another."
"So how do we make sure he's really Reiner?"
"There are two ways," Leo says. "Either he has to keep talking to you and eventually spill information that's inside this file--up-close SS information that isn't the kind of stuff you can glean from watching the History Channel 24/7. Or we need an eyewitness who remembers him from the camp." He touches the newspaper clipping and the Nazi Party registration photo. "Someone who could say that these two men are one and the same."
I look at the loaf of brioche, no longer steaming but fragrant and warm. The jam, staining the maple table. My grandmother told me that her father used to ask her a riddle: What must you break apart in order to bring a family close together?
Bread, of course.
I think of this, and even though I am not religious, I pray that she will forgive me.
"I think I know someone who can help," I say.
"Say what you want," Damian argued. "I am only trying to keep you safe."
I had opened the door, expecting Aleks, only to find the captain of the guard instead. I had told him I was busy, and this was true. This week, business had grown stronger. We could not produce enough baguettes to feed demand. The loaves, like my rolls, were sweeter than anything my father had ever baked. Aleks joked with me, and said he had a secret ingredient, but he would not tell me what it was. Then it would only be an ingredient, he said.
Now, I listened to Damian as he lectured me in my kitchen. "An upior?" I said. "Those are folktales."
"There's a reason tales get told. What else makes sense? The livestock was one thing, Ania. But this . . . this beast is going after humans."
I had heard of them, of course. Of the undead who rose from their coffins, unsatisfied, and gorged themselves on the blood of others. An upior would eat its own flesh, if it had to.
Old Sal, who sold baskets in the village square, was superstitious. She never walked near a black cat; she threw salt over her shoulder; she wore her clothes inside out the night of the full moon. She was the one who buzzed about this upior that was terrorizing our village, whispering every time we set up shop beside each other at market. You can spot them in a crowd, she had said. They live among us, with their ruddy cheeks and their red lips. And after their death, they complete their transformation. If that's already happened, it's too late. The only way to kill an upior is to cut off its head, or cleave open its heart. And the only way to protect yourself from one is to swallow its blood.
I had dismissed Old Sal's stories, and now, I would dismiss Damian's. I folded my arms. "What is it you want me to do, then?"
"It's said that you can catch an upior if you can distract it," he explained. "Once it sees a knot, it has to untie it. If there's a pile of seeds, it has to count them." Damian reached above my head, took a bag of barley grain, and dumped it on the counter.
"And why would the upior happen to wander into my bakery?"
"It's possible," Damian said, "that he's already here."
It took me a moment to understand. And then, I was furious. "So because he's an outsider, he's the easy target? Because he didn't go to school with you like all your soldier friends, or because he has a different way of pronouncing words? He's not a monster, Damian. He's just different."
"Do you really know that?" he challenged, backing me up against the wall of the brick oven. "His arrival coincided with the killings."
"He's here all night, and at home with his brother all day. When would he even have time to do the things you claim?"
"Are you with him, while he's working, watching him? Or are you asleep?"
I opened my mouth. The truth was, I had been spending more and more time in the kitchen with Aleks. I told him about my father, and about Baruch Beiler. He told me about how he'd wanted to be an architect, designing buildings so tall that you became dizzy standing on the top floors. Occasionally I fell asleep curled at the table, but when I did I always awakened to find that Aleks had carried me to my bed.
Sometimes I thought that I liked staying up late with him because I knew he'd do that.
I started to sweep the barley up with my hands, but Damian caught my wrist. "If you are so sure, then why not leave it and see what happens?"
I thought of Aleks, running with his brother from town to town. I thought of his hands at my throat, sewing me whole again. I met Damian's eyes. "All right," I said.
*
That night, I did not meet Aleks in the kitchen. I was not even there when he let himself inside. Instead, when he knocked softly on my bedroom door, I told him I was feeling ill and wanted to rest.
But I didn't. I imagined him distracted by the barley, sorting it into piles. I imagined blood on his hands and pooling in his mouth.
When I couldn't sleep, I lit a candle and crept down the hall to the kitchen.
I felt the heat through the wooden door, radiant from the oven. If I stood on my toes, I could peer through a chink in the wood. I would not have a panoramic view of the kitchen, but maybe I could see Aleks working as he usually did, allaying my worst fears.
I had a perfect view of the butcher-block table, with the bag of barley still spilled on its side.
But the pile of grains had been organized, seed by seed, into military formation.
The door swung open so suddenly I fell inside, landing on all fours. The candle I was carrying rolled out of its holder and skittered across the stone floor. As I reached for it, Aleks's boot stepped down, extinguishing the flame. "Spying on me?"
I scrambled to my feet and shook my head. My gaze was drawn to the barley, in neat rows.
"I'm a little behind in my baking," Aleks said. "I had a mess to clean up when I arrived."
I realized that he was bleeding. A bandage was wrapped around his forearm
. "You're hurt."
"It's nothing."
He looked like the man I had laughed with yesterday, when he did his impression of the town drunk. He looked like the man who had lifted me into his arms when I saw a mouse skitter across the floor and refused to walk in the kitchen until I was sure it had been caught.
He was so close, now, that I could smell peppermint on his breath; I could see the flecks of green in the molten gold of his eyes. I swallowed. "Are you what I think you are?"
Aleks did not blink. "Would it matter?"
When he kissed me, I felt like I was being consumed. I was rising, expanding from the inside, frustrated that there was skin between us, that I could not get closer. I clawed at the small of his back, my fingers slipping beneath his shirt. He held my head in the cradle of his hands, and gently, so gently that I did not even feel it, he bit my lip.
There was blood in my mouth and on his. It tasted like metal, like pain. I pulled away from him, drinking the taste of myself for the first time.
In retrospect I could only think that he was as shaken by the moment as I was. Or surely he would have heard the approach of Damian, who flung open the door with his soldiers, their bayonets trained on us.
LEO
The reason that we go to meet the people who bring us plausible tips about potential Nazis is so that we can make sure they aren't nuts. You can usually get a good reading in a few moments about whether your informant is balanced and sane, or whether she is acting on a grudge, is paranoid, or is just plain crazy.
Within moments of meeting Sage Singer I know this: she isn't trying to frame this Josef Weber guy; she has nothing to gain from turning him in.
She's incredibly sensitive because she has a scar that ripples from her left eyebrow down her cheek.
Also: because of said scar, she has no idea that she's incredibly hot.
I get it, really I do. When I was thirteen I had the worst case of acne--I swear my pimples gave birth to smaller pimples. I got called "Pepperoni Face," or Luigi, because that was the name of the guy who owned the pizzeria in my hometown. On school picture day I was so nervous about having my image captured for eternity that I actually willed myself into throwing up so I could stay home. My mother told me that when I was older, I'd teach people to never judge a book by its cover, and that's pretty much exactly what my job entails. But sometimes, when I glance in the mirror, even now, I feel like I'm still staring at that kid.
I bet whatever Sage is picturing, when she looks at her reflection, is a lot worse than what the rest of us actually see.
Genevra is the one who is dispatched to vet most of the cold callers who reach our department; I've only met two or three. They were all in their eighties, Jews who still saw the faces of their captors superimposed on everyone they happened to meet. In none of those cases did the allegation pan out to be correct.
Sage Singer is not eighty years old. And she's not lying, either.
"Your grandmother," I repeat. "She's a survivor?"
Sage nods.
"And somehow, in the past four conversations I've had with you . . . that never came up?"
I am still trying to figure out if this is a very good thing, or a very bad thing. If Sage's grandmother is willing and able to identify Reiner Hartmann as an officer at Auschwitz-Birkenau, that would be a direct link between the file Genevra's amassed and the information Sage has culled from the suspect. But if Sage has predisposed her grandmother in any way to the suspect--by saying for example that she has been talking to him--then any eyewitness testimony given is prejudicial.
"I didn't want you to think that was why I called you. It had nothing to do with my grandmother. She never talks about her experience, ever."
I lean forward, clasping my hands. "So you haven't told her about your meetings with Josef Weber?"
"No," Sage says. "She doesn't even know he exists."
"And she's never discussed her time at Auschwitz with you?"
Sage shakes her head. "Even when I've asked her, specifically, she won't talk about it." She looks up at me. "Is that normal?"
"I don't know that there's anything normal about being a survivor," I say. "Some feel that because they lived, it's their responsibility to tell the world what happened, so it won't happen again, and so people won't forget. Others believe that the only way to go on with the rest of their lives is to act as if it never happened." I sweep my crumbs into my napkin and carry my plate to the sink. "Well," I say, thinking out loud. "I can give my historian a call. She can get a photo array cobbled together in a few hours and then . . ."
"She won't talk to you, either," Sage says.
I smile. "Grandmothers find me especially charming."
She folds her arms. "If you hurt her I'll--"
"Note to self: don't threaten a federal agent. And second note to self: don't worry. I give you my word, I won't push her if she isn't able to open up about it."
"And if she does? Then what? You arrest Josef?"
I shake my head. "We don't have any criminal jurisdiction over Nazis," I explain. "We can't incarcerate your man, or set him free. The crimes took place outside the United States long before we had extraterritorial jurisdiction statutes. It wasn't until 2007 that the U.S. Genocide Statute was amended to cover more than genocides perpetrated by non-Americans outside the United States. Prior to that, it basically covered U.S. citizens other than General Custer's actions against the Native Americans. All we can do is try to catch him on immigration charges, and get him deported. And even then, I've been trying for years to get Europeans to develop a moral backbone and take Nazis back and prosecute, and it hardly ever happens."
"So we're doing all this for nothing?" Sage asks.
"We're doing all this because your grandmother made her home in the United States, and we owe her peace of mind."
Sage looks at me for a long moment. "Okay," she says. "I'll take you to her condo."
*
There are things in Reiner Hartmann's file that Sage Singer doesn't know about.
It's my job to tell her as little as possible, to instead coax out of her what she can tell me. And even then, I cannot be sure that a court will be able to connect the dots and prosecute him. I cannot be sure that Hartmann will survive long enough to receive his comeuppance.
So far, what Sage has relayed to me is information that could be gleaned from the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum archives, or from poring through a book. Military actions and dates; company units, career trajectories. Even the blood group tattoos are something you'd know about, if you study Third Reich history. As untenable as it seems that someone is making up a false guilty identity, stranger things have happened.
But in this file, there are specifics about Reiner Hartmann that only Reiner Hartmann--and his superiors, and maybe his closest confidants --should know.
None of which Sage Singer has said yet.
Which could mean that Josef Weber hasn't gotten around to telling her those stories. Or that Josef Weber isn't Reiner Hartmann.
At any rate, getting an ID from Sage's grandmother Minka is just one more piece of the puzzle. Which is how I find myself driving back toward Boston--on the exact same route I just traveled from Logan Airport to New Hampshire--with Sage sitting beside me in the car.
"That's a new one," I say. "No one in my department has ever been so upset by a testimony that they went out and hit a deer with their car."
"It wasn't intentional," Sage mutters.
"A bi gezunt."
"I beg your pardon?"
I turn to her. "It means 'so long as you're healthy.' You don't speak Yiddish, I guess."
"I'm not Jewish. I told you that."
Actually, she had asked me if it mattered. "Oh," I say. "I just assumed . . ."
"Morality has nothing to do with religion," she says. "You can do the right thing and not believe in God at all."
"So you're an atheist?"
"I don't like labels."
"I imagine you wouldn't, growing up here. Do
esn't exactly look like a diverse religious community."
"That's probably why it took Josef so long to find someone from a Jewish family," Sage says.
"Well, it doesn't really matter, since you're not going to forgive him."
She is silent.
"You're not ," I repeat, my jaw dropping. " Are you?"
"I don't want to. But there's a part of me that says he's just an old, frail man."
"One who possibly committed crimes against humanity," I reply. "And even becoming Mother Teresa wouldn't erase that. He waited over half a century to confess? That's not inherent goodness. It's procrastination."
"So you believe people can't change? That once you do a bad thing, you're a bad person?"
"I don't know," I admit. "But I do think some stains never wash out." I glance at her. "Other people in town, they knew your family was Jewish?"
"Yes."
"And Josef picked you to confess to. You aren't an individual to him any more now than a Jew was over sixty-five years ago."
"Or maybe he picked me because he thinks of me as his friend."
"Do you really believe that?" I ask, and Sage doesn't reply. "To be forgiven, the person has to be sorry. In Judaism, that's called teshuvah. It means 'turning away from evil.' It's not a one-time deal, either. It's a course of action. A single act of repentance is something that makes the person who committed the evil feel better, but not the person against whom evil was committed." I shrug. "That's why Jews don't just go to Confession, and say the rosary."
"Josef says he's already made his peace with God."
I shake my head. "You don't make peace only with God. You make it with people. Sin isn't global. It's personal. If you do wrong to someone, the only way to fix that is to go to that same person and do right by him. Which is why murder, to a Jew, is unforgivable."
She is quiet for a moment. "Have you ever had someone walk into your office and confess to you?"