'Wasn't there an artist who painted images like this?' I asked Warraner.
'Giuseppe Arcimboldo,' he replied. 'I've always meant to study up on him, but there never seems to be enough time. I imagine that he and the creators of these carvings would probably have had a lot to discuss, particularly the intimate connection between man and the natural world, had they not been separated by the ages.'
I moved to the altar and stood before the carving on the wall. If the face on the right was almost cheerful – albeit in the manner of someone who has just watched a puppy drown and found it amusing – and evoked images of the earth's bounty, this one was very different. It was a thing of roots, thorns and nettles, of briars, bare winter bushes and ivy. Branches bristling with spines poured from its open mouth and seemed both to form its features and to suffocate them, as though the image were tormenting itself. It was profoundly ugly, and startlingly, vibrantly present, an ancient being brought to life from dead things.
'It's the same visage, or the same god, depending upon one's inclination,' said Warraner from behind me.
'What?'
He pointed to his right at the face made from produce, to his left at another constructed from blossoming fowers, and fnally at a fourth face that I had not noticed before as it was above the door: a face composed of straw and leaves that had just begun to wither and die.
'All versions of a similar deity,' said Warraner. 'In the last century the name "Green Man" was coined for him: a pagan god absorbed into the Christian tradition, a symbol of death and rebirth long before the idea of the resurrection of Christ came into being. You can see why a building decorated in such a manner would have appealed to the Familists, a sect that believed in the rule of nature, not God.'
'And are you a Familist, Pastor Warraner?' I asked.
'I told you,' he answered. 'The Familists no longer exist. Frankly, it's a shame. They were outwardly tolerant of the views of others while repudiating all other religions entirely. They refused to carry arms, and they kept their opinions and beliefs to themselves. They attracted the elite, and had no time for the ignorant. If they were still around today, they'd regard most of what passes for organized religion in this country as an abomination.'
'I read that they were accused of killing to defend themselves,' I said.
'Propaganda,' said Warraner. 'Most of those allegations came from John Rogers, a sixteenth-century cleric who hated Christopher Vitel, the leader of the Familists in England. He called the Family of Love a "horrible secte", and based his attacks on depositions given by dissenting ex-Familists. There's no evidence that the Familists ever killed those who disagreed with them. Why should they? The sect's members were quietists: they didn't even publicly identify themselves, but hid among other congregations to avoid being identifed and put at risk.'
'Like religious chameleons,' I said, 'blending into the background.'
'Exactly,' said Warraner. 'Eventually they simply became what they pretended to be.'
'Except the ones who traveled here to found Prosperous.'
'And in the end even they vanished,' said Warraner.
'Why did the Familists leave England?' I said. 'It wasn't clear from the little that I could fnd out about them. As far as I can tell, religious persecution was already dying when they departed. Why fee when you're no longer threatened?'
Warraner leaned against a pew and folded his arms. It was a curiously defensive gesture.
'The Familists entered a state of schism,' he said. 'Disagreements arose between those who advocated following the Quaker way, and those who wished to adhere to the sect's original belief system. The traditionalists feared being named as something more dangerous than dissenters, particularly when it was suggested that the building we're in should be razed. They viewed this church as the wellspring of their faith, which was probably why those who had chosen to follow an alternative path so desired its destruction. A wealthy cadre of the faithful came together to save the church, and their sect, from annihilation. The result was an exodus to New England, and the founding of Prosperous.'
He glanced at his watch.
'Now, I'm sorry,' he said, 'but I really do need to get back to my kitchen closets.'
I took one more look at the largest of the faces on the wall, the image of a winter god, then thanked him and joined Morland, who had waited throughout by the door. We watched Warraner lock the chapel with a key from a heavy ring, and check that it was securely closed.
'One last thing,' I said.
'Yes?'
He sounded impatient. He wanted to be gone.
'Wasn't Christopher Vitel a joiner too?'
Warraner thrust his hands into his pockets and squinted at me. The sun was setting, and the air was growing colder, as though the chill inside the chapel had permeated the outside world while the door was open.
'You really have done your homework, Mr Parker,' he said.
'I like to keep myself informed.'
'Yes, Vitel was a joiner. It was used against him by his enemies to suggest that he was nothing but a vagabond.'
'But he was much more than that, wasn't he? I understand that he was also a textile merchant in the Low Countries, and it was there that he encountered the founder of the Familists, Hendrik Niclas, except at that time he was Christopher Vitell. He dropped the second "l" when he returned to England to spread the doctrine of the Familists, effectively giving himself a new identity.'
'That may be true,' said Warraner. 'Such changes of spelling were not uncommon at the time, and may not even have been deliberate.'
'And then,' I continued, 'around 1580, when the government of Queen Elizabeth was hunting the Familists, Vitel simply disappeared.'
'He is not present in the historical record from that time on,' said Warraner. 'It's not clear why. He may have died.'
'Or assumed another identity. A man who changed his name once could easily do so again.'
'What are you suggesting, Mr Parker?'
'Maybe preaching isn't the only talent you inherited from your genes.'
'You should have been a historian, Mr Parker. A speculative one, perhaps, but a historian nonetheless. But then, isn't historical research a form of detection too?'
'I suppose it is. I hadn't really considered it.'
'But in answer to your suggestion, I have no idea if my line stretches back to Vitel, but I would consider myself blessed indeed if that were the case.'
He tested the door one last time, and began walking toward the gate.
'It's been interesting talking to you, Mr Parker,' he called back just before he reached it. 'I hope you get to visit us again sometime.'
'I think I'll be back,' I said, but only Morland heard me.
'It's a dead end,' he said. 'Whatever you're looking for isn't here.'
'You may be right,' I said, 'but I'm not sure what it is that I'm looking for, so who's to know?'
'I thought that you were looking for a missing girl.'
'Yes,' I said, as Warraner vanished into the woods without a backward glance, 'so did I.'
Morland escorted me from the churchyard and locked the gate behind us. I thanked him for his time, got in my car and drove away. I thought he might have followed me to the town limits to make sure that I was leaving, but he didn't. When I turned right, he went left to go back to Prosperous. I kept the radio off, and played no music as I drove. I thought about Jude, and Morland, and my time with Pastor Warraner. One small detail nagged at me. It might have been nothing, but like a fragment of thorn buried in my fesh, it itched at me as I headed south, and by the time I reached Bangor it was impossible to ignore.
Warraner had not asked me anything more about Jude, or my reasons for visiting Prosperous, once we had left the subject of Jude's intrusion on the cemetery. It might simply have been the case that Warraner wasn't curious about Jude or his missing daughter. He may have become distracted as we talked about his beloved chapel. Or there was a third possibility: Warraner didn't ask about Jude because he alread
y knew that Jude was dead, but if that was so, why not mention it? Why not ask who had hired me, or why I had come so far north to ask about a homeless man? Yes, Morland could have told Warraner the reason for my visit while I was following him to the churchyard, but if so, then why would Warraner have bothered to ask me the same question a second time?
My headlights caught bare branches and twisted trees, and every shadow concealed the face of the Green Man.
24
Morland drove to the outskirts of Prosperous and sat in his car, drinking coffee from his Thermos and watching the cars enter and leave the town. His Crown Vic rested on a small hill partially concealed by trees, a site that he often used as the location for a speed trap when the mood took him. His father had shown him this location, pointing out to him the sweet spot, the perfect position from which to watch without being seen while also giving an unrestricted view of the road. On this occasion Morland left the radar gun in its case. He didn't want to be disturbed. He wanted to think.
Hayley Conyer would have to be informed of the detective's visit, and it was better that Morland should be the one to do it rather than Pastor Warraner. Who knew what poisons Warraner would pour into Hayley's ear? It was the pastor who had shouted loudest for the killing of the man named Jude, even as Morland tried to divert the board from a course of action that had now brought a dangerous man down upon them.
For the detective was dangerous, of that Morland had no doubt. The chief had not been busy when the detective arrived at the town offce, and could have seen him immediately, but he had taken time to compose himself, to run through the possible reasons for the man's visit. Morland had been surprised when the detective mentioned Jude's name, but had hidden it well. He had struggled harder to retain his composure when the detective had wanted to visit the chapel, but he shouldn't have: it was a perfectly understandable request to make given the unusual nature of the building, although Morland had offered the detective an opening by mentioning that Jude had been arrested on church grounds. As for Warraner, he regularly received letters and e-mails from interested parties asking for permission to visit, even if he was careful to limit such visits to those whose reasons were entirely without ulterior motive.
But Morland believed that the detective did nothing without an ulterior motive. He wasn't the kind of man to go sightseeing at an old church simply because he had time on his hands. He was looking for connections. Morland could only hope that he had left Prosperous without making any. The chief ran over the details of their conversation again and again, adding what he'd heard of the detective's discussion with Warraner. Morland tried to see the situation through the detective's eyes, and by the time the Thermos was empty he had decided there was nothing about the day's business that could have added to any half-formed suspicions the detective might have brought with him. It had been a fshing expedition, nothing more, and the hook had come back bare. Still, Morland hadn't like the way the detective watched Warraner as the pastor departed, or his suggestion that the girl's disappearance might not be the sole purpose of his visit. His frst hook might not have caught on anything, but the detective had left others trailing.
Morland climbed from the car and went into the bushes to take a leak. It was dark now but the moon shone silver on the small body of water known as Lady's Pond. This was where the women of Prosperous would go to congregate and bathe, undisturbed by their menfolk, in the early decades of the township. Morland wondered how many of them knew of the town's true nature, even then. Probably only a handful, he thought. More of the townsfolk understood Prosperous now, but far from all. Some chose to be blind to it, and others were deliberately kept in the dark. It was strange, thought Morland, how generations of Prosperous families had never been entrusted with the truth yet still had reaped its benefts. It was stranger still that the town's secret had remained undiscovered by outsiders over the centuries, even allowing for the killings that had occurred in order to silence those who were ready to betray it. Perhaps it was a circular argument: the town was always at risk because it required murder to survive, but by spilling blood it accrued the blessings that enabled it to keep that risk to a minimum, and assure the town's continued prosperity. Put that way, it sounded simple, logical.
Morland wondered if, like his father and grandfather before him, he had become such a monster that he almost failed to notice his own moral and spiritual deformity any more.
The issue of betrayal brought him back to the Dixons. It had been Morland's decision to place Luke Joblin's son with them. He hoped that Bryan Joblin's presence would keep the Dixons in line and force them to act according to the board's wishes, but he had his doubts. If the Dixons actually managed to produce a girl to replace Annie Broyer, Morland would give up coffee for a year.
But there was a part of the chief that hoped Harry Dixon was right – that the fact of the girl's killing and the soaking of her blood into the soil of Prosperous might be enough. The town was hurting, but not as much as the rest of the state. People were getting by. Morland imagined a situation where Pastor Warraner informed the board that all was now well and the chapel remained quiet, so no further action was required. But Warraner was both fanatical and weak, and Morland had not yet decided if the latter quality was useful or dangerous. It depended upon the circumstances, he supposed, but it meant that Warraner had a habit of attacking from behind when it came to disputes. He was no honest broker. Morland wished that Warraner's father were still alive and in charge of the chapel. Old Watkyn Warraner had been a cautious man by all accounts, and he steered the congregation through more than half a century without blood being spilt more than once. It was the longest such period of contentment that the town had known.
Well, we're paying for it now, thought Morland. Two bodies – one here and one in Portland – and it appeared that they were not enough. Now a detective was asking questions, a strange man with a reputation for excavating long-buried secrets and annihilating his enemies. Under the circumstances, Warraner could argue that the spilling of blood was more necessary than ever, for only by blood would the town be saved, and the selectmen might well be inclined to agree. They were all old and fearful – even Hayley Conyer, except that she just hid her fear better than most. Younger people were needed on the board, but most of the town's youth weren't ready to take on the burden of protecting Prosperous. It took decades for the town to seep into one's soul, for the recognition of one's obligations to it to form. It was a kind of corruption, a pollution passed down through generations, and only the oldest were corrupt and polluted enough to be able to make the tough decisions required to keep the town alive.
Morland used a bottle of water to wash his hands clean before drying them on the legs of his trousers. It was time to talk with Hayley Conyer. He called his wife and told her that he would be home late. No, he wasn't sure when. He knew only that a long evening stretched ahead.
Morland drove to the Conyer house and parked outside. The drapes were drawn on all the windows, but a sliver of light was visible from her mausoleum of a living room. He wasn't surprised to fnd her home. Unless she was out on board business, Hayley was always home. Morland couldn't remember the last time she'd left town for more than a couple of hours. She was afraid the place would collapse into the ground without her. That was part of the problem, of course.
'Bitch,' he said, softly, as he stepped from the car. The wind
whipped the word away, and he found his right hand twitching involuntarily, as if hoping to catch the insult before it reached the ear of Hayley Conyer.
He rang the doorbell, and Hayley answered.
'I'm sorry to disturb you—' Morland began to say, but Hayley held up a hand to interrupt him.
'It's quite all right,' she said. 'I've been expecting you.'
She invited him to step inside, then led him to the living room, where Pastor Warraner had already made himself at home in an armchair.
'Shit,' said Morland.
25
The woman on desk duty at th
e Tender House in Bangor was named Molly Bow, and she looked like she should have been fxed to the prow of a sailing ship. She was big and weathered, but attractive in a matronly way, and at one point I had to take a couple of steps back to avoid being crushed by her breasts as she passed me to get to a fling cabinet in her offce.
'Comin' through,' she said as I fattened my back against a wall. She gestured at her bosom. 'I was born large. Backache apart, it's been useful in life. People make an effort to get out of my way.'
Once again I had an image of a schooner or, better still, a man-of-war cleaving a path through the waves, but I kept my eyes fxed on a neutral spot on the opposite wall, well above chest height.
The Tender House had no signs outside to mark its presence. It was located in a pair of adjoining clapboard buildings surrounded by a white picket fence that was only slightly higher than those of its neighbors. Two cars were parked in the drive, which was secured by an automatically operated steel gate, also painted white. Inside the front door of the main building was a waiting room containing toys, a library of self-help books, boxes of tissues, large containers of secondhand clothes organized according to type and size, from infant to adult, and, in a discreet corner, toothbrushes, toothpaste and toiletries. Behind the reception desk was a small playroom.