In an essay titled “The Empire of Clean,” Timothy Egan, a reporter for the New York Times, observed,
In the Beehive State of Utah, nearly every town, church, and family of any standing keeps a record, a daily diary of the Mormon Dream. Typically, it is a ledger of life on two levels—one long on struggle and triumph, the story of the creation of Zion in the American West, the other more spiritual but no less detailed. They know in Orderville exactly who was hungry in 1912 and who committed adultery in 1956, but they also know whether somebody's ancestor from the fifteenth century has been given a valid passport to eternal life. Every wagon train drama, every horrific entry from the epic, killing mistake of the handcart migration, every basketball championship over the Indian kids in Carbon County, is written down, somewhere. No state has more keepers of history, or better archives, honeycombed in climate-controlled vaults, than Utah. . . . Mormons have made a workaday craftsmanship of keeping the past alive. There is a record, the Saints like to say, of everything.
I availed myself of this rich history by draining my bank account in bookstores near and far. I also made several visits to the archives of the Utah State Historical Society in Salt Lake City, and the Harold B. Lee Library at Brigham Young University, in Provo. During my reading, I was struck by the impact three writers, in particular, have made on the interpretation of Mormon history: Fawn Brodie, the author of No Man Knows My History; Juanita Brooks, the author of The Mountain Meadows Massacre; and D. Michael Quinn, the author of Early Mormonism and the Magic World View, The Mormon Hierarchy: Origins of Power, and The Mormon Hierarchy: Extensions of Power.
Each of these historians was born into the Mormon Church, and their faith (or loss thereof, in Brodie's case) informed and enhanced their scholarship, which is distinguished by its courageous, unflinching honesty. Brodie died in 1981, and Brooks in 1989, but Quinn, currently fifty-eight years old, is still a productive scholar at the height of his intellectual powers. Quinn's writing lacks the eloquence of Brodie's and the unembellished narrative force of Brooks's, and as a consequence his books have not been widely read by the general public. The influence of his prodigious work, however, has been huge among Mormon historians. And no writer since Fawn Brodie has provoked such intense condemnation from the LDS General Authorities.
Quinn studied as an undergraduate at BYU, went on to receive a doctorate from Yale, and then returned to BYU as an inspired professor of history. He first aroused the ire of LDS leaders in 1981, when he presented a now-famous lecture to the BYU Student History Association. Titled “On Being a Mormon Historian,” it was a response to a recent attack on those academics, like Quinn, who dared to publish work that was critical of the church's official, extensively expurgated version of Mormon history. “The tragic reality,” he declared in his lecture, “is that there have been occasions when Church leaders, teachers, and writers have not told the truth they knew about difficulties of the Mormon past, but have offered to the Saints instead a mixture of platitudes, half-truths, omissions, and plausible denials.”
Quinn argued, “A so-called ‘faith-promoting' Church history which conceals controversies and difficulties of the Mormon past actually undermines the faith of Latter-day Saints who eventually learn about the problems from other sources. One of the most painful demonstrations of that fact has been the continued spread of unauthorized polygamy among the Latter-day Saints during the last seventy-five years, despite the concerted efforts of Church leaders to stop it.” Quinn pointed out that after officially renouncing the doctrine of plural marriage in 1890, the highest leaders in fact continued to sanction polygamy, covertly, for many years. And this casuistry, he insisted, has driven many Mormons into the embrace of fundamentalism.
“The central argument of the enemies of the LDS Church,” Quinn said, “is historical, and if we seek to build the Kingdom of God by ignoring or denying the problem areas of our past, we are leaving the Saints unprotected. As one who has received death threats from anti-Mormons because they perceive me as an enemy historian, it is discouraging to be regarded as subversive by men I sustain as prophets, seers, and revelators.”
The text of Quinn's lecture, which resonated strongly among Mormon intellectuals, was printed on the front page of an underground student newspaper, infuriating the LDS General Authorities in Salt Lake City and sparking a raging controversy that made the pages of Newsweek magazine. It was the beginning of Quinn's fall from grace in the church he loved. By 1988 he was pressured into resigning his tenured professorship at BYU. And in 1993, following a highly publicized hearing by an LDS “disciplinary council,” he became one of six prominent Mormon scholars who were excommunicated from the LDS Church for apostasy. “The church wanted to send a very public message to dissidents,” Quinn says. “Their goal was intimidation, to silence dissent.”
Banishment from the church came as a harsh blow. “Even if you have all kinds of objections to church policies,” he explains, “when you're a believing Mormon, to be excommunicated is like a form of death. It's like attending your own funeral. You feel the loss of that sense of community. I miss it deeply.”
Quinn's standing in the LDS Church was not helped by the fact that in the mid-1980s he revealed that he is gay; the Mormon General Authorities continue to make the church a very difficult place for homosexuals. Despite Mormonism's entrenched homophobia, and Quinn's unsparing, clear-eyed assessment of Mormonism's faults, his faith in the religion of Joseph Smith remains undiminished. “I'm a radical believer,” he says, “but I'm still a believer.” He seems to be one of those rare spiritual thinkers, as Annie Dillard puts it, who possess “a sort of anaerobic capacity to batten and thrive on paradox.”
“At a very early age,” Quinn acknowledges, “I developed what I call ‘a complex testimony.' Instead of a black/white view of Mormonism, I have an Old Testament sort of faith. The writers of the Old Testament presented the prophets as very human vessels, warts and all. Yet God still chose them to be His leaders on earth. That's how I see Mormonism: It is not a perfect church. It has huge flaws, in both the institution and the people who lead it. They are only human. And I have no trouble accepting that. It's all part of my faith.
“On the very first page of The Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith wrote that if it contained mistakes or faults, ‘it be the mistakes of men.' And this same thing is stated in various ways throughout the text that follows—that errors in this sacred book are possible, even likely. I have always believed that Mormonism was the one true church, but I don't think it has ever been infallible. And I certainly don't believe it has a monopoly on the truth.”
One of the events that led to Dr. Quinn's excommunication was the publication, in 1987, of Early Mormonism and the Magic World View, a fascinating, exhaustively researched examination of Joseph Smith's involvement in mysticism and the occult. In the preface to a revised 1998 edition of the book, Quinn astutely observed that “many academics feel embarrassed for a scholar who even briefly acknowledges belief in the metaphysical.” He argued, nevertheless, that authors had an intellectual and ethical responsibility “to state one's own frame of reference when writing about the metaphysical”—which he proceeded to do, succinctly describing his Mormon faith. And regarding that faith, he wrote, “I make no apologies to secular humanists or religious polemicists.”
I happen to find Quinn's argument compelling. He's convinced me that those who write about religion owe it to their readers to come clean about their own theological frame of reference. So here's mine:
I don't know what God is, or what God had in mind when the universe was set in motion. In fact, I don't know if God even exists, although I confess that I sometimes find myself praying in times of great fear, or despair, or astonishment at a display of unexpected beauty.
There are some ten thousand extant religious sects—each with its own cosmology, each with its own answer for the meaning of life and death. Most assert that the other 9,999 not only have it completely wrong but are instruments of evil, besides. None of
the ten thousand has yet persuaded me to make the requisite leap of faith. In the absence of conviction, I've come to terms with the fact that uncertainty is an inescapable corollary of life. An abundance of mystery is simply part of the bargain—which doesn't strike me as something to lament. Accepting the essential inscrutability of existence, in any case, is surely preferable to its opposite: capitulating to the tyranny of intransigent belief.
And if I remain in the dark about our purpose here, and the meaning of eternity, I have nevertheless arrived at an understanding of a few more modest truths: Most of us fear death. Most of us yearn to comprehend how we got here, and why—which is to say, most of us ache to know the love of our creator. And we will no doubt feel that ache, most of us, for as long as we happen to be alive.
JON KRAKAUER
JANUARY 2003
Bibliography
Altman, Irwin, and Joseph Ginat. Polygamous Families in Contemporary Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 4th ed. (DSM-IV). Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association, 1994.
Anderson, Kenneth. “The Magic of the Great Salt Lake.” Times Literary Supplement, March 24, 1995.
———. “A Peculiar People: The Mystical and Pragmatic Appeal of Mormonism.” Los Angeles Times, November 28, 1999.
Arbaugh, George Bartholomew. Revelations in Mormonism: Its Character and Changing Forms. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1932.
Armstrong, Karen. The Battle for God. New York: Ballantine Books, 2001.
———. Buddha. New York: Viking Penguin, 2001.
———. A History of God: The 4,000-Year Quest of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. New York: Ballantine Books, 1994.
Arrington, Leonard J. Adventures of a Church Historian. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1998.
———. Brigham Young: American Moses. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1984.
Arrington, Leonard J., and Davis Bitton. The Mormon Experience: A History of the Latter-day Saints. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1979.
Bagley, Will. Blood of the Prophets: Brigham Young and the Massacre at Mountain Meadows. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2002.
Bancroft, Hubert Howe. History of Utah, 1540–1886. San Francisco: History Company, 1889.
Bayle, Pierre. Historical and Critical Dictionary: Selections. Translated, with an introduction and notes, by Richard H. Popkin. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill Company, 1965.
Belshaw, Michael. “The Dunn-Howland Killings: A Reconstruction.” Journal of Arizona History, vol. 20 (winter 1979).
Bigler, David L. Forgotten Kingdom: The Mormon Theocracy in the American West, 1847–1896. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1998.
Bishop, William, ed. Mormonism Unveiled; or the Life and Confessions of the Late Mormon Bishop, John D. Lee. Albuquerque: Fierra Blanca Publications, 2001.
Bistline, Benjamin. The Polygamists: A History of Colorado City. Colorado City, Ariz.: Benjamin Bistline, 1998.
Bloom, Harold. The American Religion: The Emergence of the Post-Christian Nation. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1992.
Bradlee, Ben Jr., and Dale Van Atta. Prophet of Blood: The Untold Story of Ervil LeBaron and the Lambs of God. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons, 1981.
Bradley, Martha Sonntag. Kidnapped from That Land: The Government Raids on the Short Creek Polygamists. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1996.
Bringhurst, Newell G. Brigham Young and the Expanding American Frontier. Boston: Little, Brown and Co., 1986.
———. Fawn McKay Brodie: A Biographer's Life. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1999.
———. Saints, Slaves, and Blacks: The Changing Place of Black People Within Mormonism. Westport: Greenwood Press, 1981.
———, ed. Reconsidering No Man Knows My History: Fawn M. Brodie and Joseph Smith in Retrospect. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1996.
Brodie, Fawn M. The Devil Drives: A Life of Sir Richard Burton. New York: W. W. Norton, 1967.
———. No Man Knows My History: The Life of Joseph Smith, the Mormon Prophet. 2nd ed. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1995.
Brooke, John L. The Refiner's Fire: The Making of Mormon Cosmology, 1644–1844. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Brooks, Juanita. Emma Lee. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1984.
———. John Doyle Lee: Zealot, Pioneer Builder, Scapegoat. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1992.
———. The Mountain Meadows Massacre. Foreword and afterword by Jan Shipps. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991.
Burton, Richard F. The City of the Saints and Across the Rocky Mountains to California. Edited, with an introduction and notes, by Fawn M. Brodie. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1963.
Bush, Lester E. Jr. “A Peculiar People: The Physiological Aspects of Mormonism 1850–1975.” Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, vol. 12, no. 3 (fall 1979).
Bushman, Claudia L., ed. Mormon Sisters: Women in Early Utah. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1997.
Bushman, Richard L. Joseph Smith and the Beginnings of Mormonism. Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1984.
Campbell, Carolyn. “Fugitive Witness: Tom Green's Ex-wife Defends Her Decision to Let Her Daughter Marry Her Husband.” Salt Lake City Weekly, February 22, 2001.
Card, Brigham Y., Herbert C. Northcott, John E. Foster, Howard Palmer, and George K. Jarvis, eds. The Mormon Presence in Canada. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press, 1990.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. “The Book of Mormon,” “The Doctrine and Covenants,” “The Pearl of Great Price.” One-volume edition. Salt Lake City: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 1981.
Chynoweth, Rena, with Dean M. Shapiro. The Blood Covenant. Austin: Diamond Books, 1990.
Cleland, Robert Glass, and Juanita Brooks, eds. A Mormon Chronicle: The Diaries of John D. Lee, 1848–1876. 2 vols. San Marino, Calif.: Huntington Library, 1955.
Compton, Todd. In Sacred Loneliness: The Plural Wives of Joseph Smith. Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 1997.
Corbett, Pearson Harris. Jacob Hamblin: The Peacemaker. Salt Lake City: Deseret Book Co., 1952.
Crapanzano, Vincent. Serving the Word: Literalism in America from the Pulpit to the Bench. New York: New Press, 2000.
Crossfield, Robert (Onias). The First Book of Commandments. Salem, Utah: United Order Publications, 1998.
———. The Second Book of Commandments. Salem, Utah: United Order Publications, 1999.
Dellenbaugh, Frederick S. A Canyon Voyage: The Narrative of the Second Powell Expedition down the Green-Colorado River from Wyoming, and the Explorations on Land, in the Years 1871 and 1872. Tucson: University of Arizona Press, 1996.
“A Den of Treason: That's What John Taylor Made the Assembly Hall Last Sunday.” Salt Lake Daily Tribune, January 6, 1880.
DeVoto, Bernard. The Year of Decision: 1846. Boston: Little, Brown and Co., 1943.
Dewey, Richard Lloyd, ed. Jacob Hamblin: His Life in His Own Words. New York: Paramount Books, 1995.
Dillard, Annie. For the Time Being. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1999.
———. Holy the Firm. New York: Harper & Row, 1977.
Dobyns, Henry F., and Robert C. Euler. “The Dunn-Howland Killings: Additional Insights.” Journal of Arizona History, vol. 21 (spring 1980).
Dolnick, Edward. Down the Great Unknown: John Wesley Powell's 1869 Journey of Discovery and Tragedy Through the Grand Canyon. New York: HarperCollins, 2001.
Dougherty, John. “Polygamy in Arizona: The Wages of Sin.” Phoenix New Times, April 10, 2003.
Durham, Michael S. Desert Between the Mountains: Mormons, Miners, Padres, Mountain Men, and the Opening of the Great Basin, 1772–1869. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1999.
Egan, Timothy. Lasso the Wind: Away to the New West. New York: Vintage, 1999.
Embry, Jessie L. Black Saints in a White Church: Contemporary African American Mormons. Salt Lake
City: Signature Books, 1994.
Ferguson, Charles W. The Confusion of Tongues: A Review of Modern Isms. Garden City, New York: Doubleday, Doran & Co., 1928.
Fielding, Robert Kent. The Unsolicited Chronicler: An Account of the Gunnison Massacre, Its Causes and Consequences, Utah Territory, 1847–1859—a Narrative History. Brookline, Mass.: Paradigm Publications, 1993.
———, ed. The “Tribune” Reports of the Trials of John D. Lee for the Massacre at Mountain Meadows, November 1874–April 1877. Higganum, Conn.: Kent's Books, 2000.
Fishman, Ted C. “Unholy Voices?” Playboy, vol. 39, no. 11 (November 1992).
Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. The Four Hidden Revelations. Salt Lake City: Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, n.d.
Gilmore, Mikal. Shot in the Heart. New York: Anchor, 1995.
Givens, Terryl L. By the Hand of Mormon: The American Scripture That Launched a New World Religion. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002.
Gottfredson, Peter. Indian Depredations. Salt Lake City: 1919.
Green, Arnold H., and Lawrence P. Goldrup. “Joseph Smith, an American Muhammad? An Essay on the Perils of Historical Analogy.” Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought, vol. 6, no. 1 (spring 1971).
Green, Tom. “Why We Talk to the Media.” www.polygamy.com/Mormon/Why-We-Talk-To-The-Media.htm.
Greene, Graham. The End of the Affair. New York: Viking, 1961.
Gunnison, Lieutenant J. W. The Mormons, or Latter-Day Saints, in the Valley of the Great Salt Lake: A History of Their Rise and Progress, Peculiar Doctrines, Present Condition, and Prospects, Derived from Personal Observation, During a Residence Among Them. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1860. Reprint, Brookline, Mass.: Paradigm Publications, 1993.
Hallwas, John E., and Roger D. Launius, eds. Cultures in Conflict: A Documentary History of the Mormon War in Illinois. Logan: Utah State University Press, 1995.